Dismal for despots, but not necessarily superb for socialists — that’s the last two years or so.
Donald Trump and the Republicans have lost both houses of Congress in the US mid-terms on 3 November. Self-enrichment by his family and entourage, rising prices, and the Iran war have sapped his support.
His eve-of-poll speech in which he said he could have won the Vietnam war “in a week” by bombing Ho Chi Minh City won’t have helped. Ho Chi Minh City was then Saigon, the stronghold of the US-allied South Vietnam government.
But Trump has amassed wide powers to rule without reference to Congress. And the Democrats are timid politically.
In Hungary Viktor Orbán seemed unbeatable after 16 years in power “colonising” the media and political system. He lost the April 2026 election, and his replacement Peter Magyar seems able to purge the state machinery and mend relations with the EU (see page 19). Yet Magyar keeps conservative social policy and the razor-wire border fences against refugees.
Bangladesh: in July 2024 student revolt brought down the 15-year and increasingly corrupt and authoritarian rule of the Awami League. The students had no political party to replace it. Since February 2026 Bangladesh is ruled by the more conservative of Bangladesh’s two big traditional parties, the BNP. Garment workers are striking against still-low wages.
Students
Nepal: students brought down the old Maoist-led government in September 2025. Again, they had no political alternative. Since March 2026 elections the country has been ruled by a demagogue who affects dark glasses in his official portrait.
Madagascar: student revolt brought down the government in October 2025, but to install a military ruler.
Serbia: Vucic lost the 25 October election, but the victorious Student List is not the students themselves but “professionals” and “technocrats” endorsed by them, with little clear programme beyond curbing corruption.
India: Narendra Modi, the Hindu chauvinist in power since 2014, is challenged more than ever by a youth revolt. Modi is responding by purging 131 million names from electoral rolls, but even without that he faces no clear positive alternative.
France: huge youth revolt, and setpiece mostly-public-service strikes, but when Macron steps down in April-May, Marine Le Pen is way ahead to replace him. She has a fascist past, a cleaned-up “hard-right” present, and, as some writers put it, a very possible “fascist future”.
Much follows the patterns of the 2010s. Youth revolt brought down despots like Mubarak in Egypt and Ben Ali in Tunisia, but had no political alternative. Soon Sisi, worse than Mubarak, was ruling Egypt. Some democracy lasted longer in Tunisia, thanks to the existence there of a sizeable but weak trade union movement, the UGTT, but since 2021 Tunisia has a new despot.
Alternative
In Brazil, leftish protests against Dilma Rousseff’s Workers’ Party regime, as it responded neoliberally to world economic turmoil lacked a political alternative, were hijacked by the right, and led to the right-wing Temer and Bolsonaro regimes. Lula of the Workers’ Party has won the latest presidential election, but is tied to policies more conservative than when first president.
Three lessons emerge:
• Negative down-with-corruption politics, though it may be an unavoidable starting point, is not enough.
• For workers to play a shaping role, trade unions have to rebuild strength not just in public-service sectors where one-day or even many-day strikes have less clout, but at the chokepoints of profit-making. And they need politics.
• Politics needs politics: not just revolt, but a political force with a widely-understood alternative programme. Socialists have to win people to our positive ideas, not just hope to surf on revolt. That’s why we publish Solidarity.
Edited to reflect results of the US elections.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us