In a case from 2023, after Tory Health Minister Steve Barclay saying that the NHS would block trans women from women’s wards, a 27-year old trans woman, Joelle, died after a 16-day delay in cancer treatment at Wolverhampton NHS Trust. Similar delays could become more common with new guidelines from 15 October.
Joelle had an aggressive lymphoma, but if treated she could have recovered. A bed was available on the cancer ward when she arrived, and she was initially taken there. Staff then saw she was trans. She was returned to A&E for 12 hours and then put alone in a side room on a ward on the far side of the hospital.
She was refused the cancer-ward bed because it was in a multi-bed women’s ward. She had asked for a bed on either the male or female ward. Staff told her and her mother that emergency chemotherapy could not start until she was on the “right” ward. She waited 16 days for a rare single room.
During that time she was given no cancer pain management. By the time chemotherapy began, it was too late.
The Trans Legal Clinic is helping to get an Article 2 inquest, which could examine systemic failures. It is also helping with a clinical negligence claim.
Yet an internal memo from NHS England has said (the Guardian reports) that new guidance on single-sex hospital accommodation could have “a number of potential adverse impacts” for trans people. The guidance, from 15 October, says single-sex wards, toilets and changing rooms should be used according to biological sex, not gender identity.
The assessment says trans patients may face delays and a greater risk of “corridor care” if side rooms are unavailable. Even if not, trans patients are now likely to experience discrimination by being “outed” through where they are placed. Hospitals lacking side-room capacity could force trans people onto wards matching their birth-sex. It increases the likelihood that some may avoid healthcare altogether.
Also, cisgender women who do not “present in line with general societal expectations” could face invasive questioning.
The policy does not apply in A&E or intensive care, and says single-sex accommodation should not be a reason for corridor care.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us