Ireland then and now

Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@mhabegger?utm_source=unsplash&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=creditCopyText">Mathieu Habegger</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/an-empty-road-with-a-hill-in-the-background-RUNldEO8f0s?utm_source=unsplash&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a>

I first visited Ireland in December 1969. Back then there were no motorways and only one bit of dual carriageway, 22 miles, from Dublin to Naas. I got a lift from Dublin to Belfast, but the driver had to go back because a lorry have overturned and blocked the road, so I ended up getting the train.

I remember a house in a small town where they had that rare thing, a telephone. You had to crank up a handle on it so the local operator could put you call through and no doubt listen in for the gossip!

In Dublin I encountered youthful members of the Legion of Mary, who made an unsuccessful attempt to rescue my heathen soul.

Nowadays there are over 900 km of motorway (they don’t do miles anymore) and everyone has a mobile phone. The modern tram system in Dublin is another sign of the country’s relatively recent modernisation.

If you suggested fifty years ago that the Irish people would vote two to one in favour of same sex marriage or to legalise abortion you would have been dismissed as a fantasist.

By GDP per capita Ireland is the richest country in Europe. The figure is artificially boosted by multinationals running their income through Ireland for the sake of low taxes there. However, Ireland’s economy has improved beyond recognition from what it was half a century ago.

A major reason for this is membership of the European Union. 93% of the population have a favourable view of EU membership — the highest approval of any member state. That wasn’t always the case. In 1973, Sinn Fein campaigned against EEC entry. It dropped its anti-EU stance in the 1990s.

Which brings us back to Spike and the need for more people. Currently the population of Ireland stands at around 7.3 million including the 1.9 million living in the Northern Ireland six counties, up from 4.2 million in 1961 though still down on the 8.5 million who lived there just before the Great Famine of 1845-48.

That Ireland now imports rather than exports more people has certainly reversed the population doomsday scenario much feared in yesteryear. Around a quarter of recent immigrants are members of the Irish diaspora “returning to the old sod”, a similar number are from the EU, and just over 50% have come from non-EU countries.

Racism

The change has led to the emergence of nasty currents of racism. No significant far right anti-immigrant “populist” party has emerged, but pessimists might say it won’t be long in coming.

Ireland’s far right unexpectedly came to notice in September 2023 when 200 of them blockaded Leinster House, seat of the Irish parliament in Dublin, putting the building in virtual lockdown for hours. Protesters threatened staff and journalists and in 6 January Trumpist style erected a mock gallows with photos of politicians from across the political spectrum on it. For good measure they hurled racist insults at anyone of colour who happened to cross their path and threw bags of urine at two women bystanders.

This was a harbinger to the worst riot in modern Dublin history two months later following the stabbing of three young children and a care assistant by a mentally ill man of Algerian origin who had been living in Ireland for two decades. In the age of the internet it took just over three hours for the far right to summon up a riot resulting in arson, vandalism and looting as well as assaults on Gardaí and members of the public.

Fortunately nothing on that scale has occurred again so far. Leading anti-immigrant personalities largely appear to be from the criminal community and notably include martial artist Conor McGregor, who, despite facing several sexual assault charges, was a welcome guest at the White House last year.

Then there is ex gangster Gerry “The Monk” Hutch, recently acquitted of a murder charge but still being investigated for money laundering, who stood in a recent by-election in Dublin Central. Not particularly well disposed towards the Somali community, Hutch stood as an independent and garnered 12% of the vote, coming in fourth, one place ahead of the Fine Gael candidate whose party had previously occupied the seat.

A revealing episode in that campaign was the secret filming of former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern talking about immigration whilst out canvassing for his Fianna Fáil. Ahern said he was OK with arrivals from Ukraine, but “the ones I worry about are the Africans.” You don’t need a lot of thought to work out why Ahern distinguished between the two groups. That such a senior Irish politician could make such remarks might signify anti-immigrant sentiment is pretty close to entering the Republic’s political mainstream.

Tightening

There are already signs the coalition government is “tightening up” immigration laws and citizenship requirements. Sinn Fein, the main opposition party, is also shifting to the right on immigration, with its leader Mary Lou McDonald claiming to have “heard the message” on immigration. It’s said Sinn Féin’s previously supportive stance regarding refugees led to a slump in its vote at the 2024 general election when it had expected to win enough seats to form a government; but a rightward move could well alienate those aged under 35, who make up more than 60% of SF’s voters.

Recent experience has shown only too clearly that moving to the right on immigration doesn’t combat the forward march of the far right, but instead emboldens them more. Socialist solutions are therefore needed in answer to problems a capitalist economy cannot solve but immigrants get the blame for.

Comments?
We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.