Stan, an activist with the NPA-R in Montpellier, spoke to us.
Politically, this year was going to be all about the Presidential election which will take place on 18 April and 2 May 2027. But this movement has focused everyone’s minds on what is happening in the here and now. It’s reframing the whole political discourse in France.
Politicians are saying “why are you protesting now? You’re going to have an election soon.” But students are answering, saying “our social movement is now and if we are to win concessions from the government, we will have to get them now.” They are right.
My impression is the far right is a lot less vocal because they are defending the same policies as Macron. Macron is already saying that the protests are controlled by the hard left, the police are the best, and so on. It’s hard for the far right to add their own voice.
People feel in general that Mélenchon is on the side of the mobilisation. The government is demonising his organisation, La France Insoumise (“France Unbowed”, LFI), and saying that he’s orchestrating the protests, but this is self-defeating because it just makes him more popular with young people. In this movement he and other LFI representatives are being rather cautious. While their main goal is to say to people: “vote for us next year”, and they have an electoralist rather than activist outlook, they are positioning themselves firmly on the side of these mobilisations.
The protest on 17 October was intended to develop an alliance between gilets jaunes (yellow vests protestors) and the lycée students. As I said before, the movement had started with bread and butter issues around schools and colleges, but it’s now more broadly about the right to have a future. However, on 24 and 31 October the protests were banned by the Prefects of both Montpellier and Paris. Challenges were lodged against the bans in court, but these were not successful. Instead, “manifs sauvages” or “wildcat demonstration” took place, chased by the police through the town.
Normally a manif sauvage is a few hundred people. This time it was tens of thousands of mostly young people who were ready to challenge the ban. Lots of people have told me that they were afraid of getting beaten up, given the fact that people have lost teeth and limbs to police violence, but we said “we’ll do it anyway”, because it is not the government’s right to tell us whether we can protest. I took part very peacefully but got teargassed all the same.
The government has made a lot of announcements but these are all complete bullshit, really. Next week will be decisive in view of the trade union mobilisation called for 5 November. This may mark a second wind for the movement. Highschool kids can’t spend the whole rest of the year going head-to-head with the government alone. So we need workers to join them.
The government is saying: go back to school, this situation is not acceptable. There’s an election in six months, so if people disagree, they can vote then.
Lycée students are, I think, a bit tired. The most political of them, the ones involved in the coordination at the national level, they are saying that they need the workers to join them.
Strong
Sophie Binet, the head of the CGT is saying “workers should join the youth”. But this 5 November protest was announced a month ago, when the movement was very strong. So we saw it not exactly as a betrayal but as calculated to have the trade union mobilisation fall after the movement had run out of steam. The bad scenario we might foresee is that the movement ebbs, and then the unions have their one protest, negotiate some and wrap it all up.
The government is saying that there needs to be debates within lycées as a form of negotiations — away from the influence of the “ultra-left”, which Macron claims is responsible for all the disorder. Thus far, Macron’s response has been all stick and no the carrot. The carrot that he is showing now is rather weak.
Politically, the movement has made things more polarised, on both left and right. A railworker friend was saying that in the context of the movement, people are voicing their thoughts more bluntly. So while many of his colleagues are sympathetic to the demands of the movement, some more reactionary colleagues felt emboldened to say that the cops should shoot the students. On the left, too, people are becoming more confirmed and strident in their beliefs.
In universities, some movement is happening. There are debates about how to proceed. A coordination of university students is happening today [1 November]. There is a plan for occupations. That means taking over whole university buildings, stopping classes, and running events, talks, film screenings, instead of normal teaching. But this cuts against “massification” of the movement. Students did an occupation in the university at Montpellier, ran all these great events, produced our own food and so on. It was a good time.
But doing all of that, we didn’t go out and do outreach. So it was 200 more political people running the occupation but they were not out talking to the 8,000 other students, who weren’t so engaged. I think radical students have a tendency, if they have enough people to pull off an occupation, to be less interested in doing outreach to others.
Some national delegates’ meetings, “coordinations” of lycée students, have taken place. There are about 4,000 lycées in France. According to the ministry, about 1,500 have been affected by the movement, maybe more. Now the lycée coordination we have built embraces at most 70-80 high schools. So it’s a small minority. The debates that we have had in these coordinations are confirming the attitudes we hear from lycée students at a local level: that we need the workers to join us, but also that the announcements of the government are bogus. The government is trying to pit good protestors against rioters, and the coordination has clearly refused to allow the government to divide them like that.
It’s simply too hard to tell now, in advance, how many workers will join in the strike action on 5 November. Will workers be passive? Or will they want to join in because they are angry at seeing their kids get beaten up? On the rails, you have to declare your intent to strike a few days in advance. So on Tuesday those declarations will come in. The teachers clearly will be on strike because the demands of the lycée mobilisation concern them directly. For the rest of society, it’s hard to say. The price of petrol is very high, and this might have provoked a gilets jaunes movement, but it’s not automatic. Macron has said he’s going to axe Parcoursup [the hated French online version of UCAS, an online platform] next year. But changing the name of the software for university admissions won’t have any affect if you don’t hire more staff.
For now I and my comrades are trying to get our core message across to the movement. I would sum it up as: don’t trust the government, don’t trust politicians, organise yourselves.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us