From Marxist Ideas To Turn The Tide, 2013, and originally from the 1976-7 discussions for a Manifesto of the I-CL (forerunner of AWL).
The nature of our action programme
The section from the 1977 “manifesto” of the International-Communist League (forerunner of AWL) which explained our idea of transitional demands and transitional programme.
A socialist programme of action is neither an option nor an arbitrarily chosen weapon for a party with the politics and the goals of the I-CL. Its nature sums up the essential content of our politics — proletarian self-liberation.
It expresses the most advanced lessons of the attempts by the proletariat between 1848 and 1919 to hammer out a political practice which linked the goal of socialist revolution with the day to day organic struggle imposed on the working class by capitalism.
In the epoch of social democracy, before the great international labour movement collapsed into national fragments at the feet of the warring bourgeoisies in 1914, socialists operated with a minimum programme and a maximum programme.
The maximum programme was the millennium, the unseen goal in the far distance, the subject of abstract propaganda, holiday speeches and moral uplift; the theoretical property of an elite within the loose parties of social democracy. The minimum programme consisted of limited practical goals and the immediate aims of the everyday struggle of the working class.
What was the link between the two? The party and the trade unions, being built in the struggles and through propaganda. (A sect like IS today provides a minuscule historical fossil for students of the tragedy of the Second International and its methods).
Capitalism was advancing organically; so was the labour movement. The “right” Social Democrats saw the process continuing indefinitely until capitalism became transformed by its own evolution, of which the evolution of the labour movement was part. “The movement is everything, the goal nothing”, said their theoretician Eduard Bernstein. The mainstream Left believed evolution involved qualitative breaks and leaps, and that the evolutionary process would have to culminate in a revolutionary proletarian seizure of power.
Both failed to link the daily class struggle with the goal of socialism. For the right, accommodating to capitalism and moulding what it could of the labour movement accordingly, this separation made sense, and their rigorous thinkers attempted to make theoretical sense of it. For the left, the separation led to sterile “maximalism” and hollow “orthodoxy” (Kautsky).
In practice, control and hegemony was left in the hands of those whose practice corresponded accurately to the minimum/maximum model; in turn, this overweening reality of the labour movement led the “orthodox” left to accommodate to the right. Ultimately, having won one hollow verbal victory after another in debate, they capitulated to the Right in practice.
Central to both wings of mainstream Social Democracy, for differing reasons but with the same consequences, was the same failure. They failed to see in the creative self-controlling activity of the working class — including workers who were initially, at the beginning of struggle in which they could learn, formally backward politically — the central force for socialism.
Left and right had in common a bureaucratic, elitist conception of socialism Their operational image of the relationship of the revolutionary party to the revolutionary class was one of pedagogic teacher to passive pupil, or self-substituting bureaucratic instrument to inert mass.
Rosa Luxemburg, first, in company with the orthodox “left”, exposed the relapse to utopian socialism implicit in Bernsteinian “revisionism” and also the relapse to the substance of utopia-building within capitalism involved in reformist practice.
She then, by 1910, came to understand the empty futility of the political victories of the “orthodox” and the practical impotence of those, like Kautsky, who accommodated to the dominant forces in the Second International. She learned from the tremendous self-mobilisations of, especially, the working class in the Tsarist empire during the 1905-7 Revolution, and came to see the reality of European Social Democracy clearly.
The Russian Bolsheviks did not see the nature of the European “left” until it capitulated to the openly chauvinist right in 1914 — but they did, right through, relate to the central truth of Marxist socialism which the tremendous combativity and creativity of the Russian working class kept before their eyes.
They had the advantage over Luxemburg and her small circle in Germany of not over-reacting to a bureaucratised, routinised, essentially elitist party, which they could only see a future for by looking to the explosive latent creative power of the working class to correct it “when the time came”. The Bolsheviks built a revolutionary party which was uniquely sensitive to the creativity of the working class, in tune with the central and
irreplaceable chord of Marxist socialism; which learned from the working class, absorbed the lessons of its struggles, synthesised them with the experiences of the international struggle, and codified them scientifically — thus educating a stable cadre.
The communist movement, reorganising itself during and immediately after World War One, resolved to have done with the minimum/ maximum division, with its inescapable consignment of the masses to passivity vis-a-vis the struggle for socialism, which the leaders would talk of and History would take care of.
The central thread of their revolutionary conceptions was summed up in the idea of Soviets (workers’ councils) — at the same time the broadest, most responsive, most democratic and most effective means for the immediate struggle against capitalism, and the essential organs of the revolutionary proletarian regime. (Significantly, the first notion of a transitional programme is expressed in Trotsky’s analysis of the 1905 Russian Revolution — the revolution that first produced Soviets).
Resolved to mobilise the working class to fight immediately for socialism, the communist movement elaborated the conception of a transitional programme — to link the everyday struggle of the working class with the goal of socialist revolution; to focus every struggle so as to rouse working class masses and direct those masses against the pillars of capitalist society.
Luxemburg, at the foundation of the Communist Party of Germany in 1919 (shortly before her assassination) and the Communist International at the 3rd and 4th Congresses began to elaborate such a concept.
The Communist Parties attempted to root themselves in the immediate working class struggles and relate those struggles to an overall struggle for socialism. They began to bring ‘socialist’ propaganda down from the cloudy skies and harness it to the hard daily grind of working class struggle.
The full socialist programme was broken down into a linked chain, each link of which might successively be grasped, and the movement hauled forward, dependent on the degree of mobilisation, intensity of struggles, and the relationship of forces.
Everyday demands, as on wages, were expressed not within the framework of acceptance of a capitalism that the socialists believed to be maturing towards some optimum time for ripeness, when it would fall. They were expressed against capitalism, so as to challenge capitalist prerogatives and the assumptions of capitalist society on a day-to-day basis.
This transitional programme, in the hands of a party organised for immediate war on capitalism and neglecting at the same time neither general propaganda nor the most “minimalist” concerns — that was the weapon that the communists armed themselves with (though the Comintern never actually formalised a transitional programme).
It summed up the pillars of the bitter post-1914 knowledge on which Marxist socialism reconstructed itself — War on capitalism, not coexistence with capitalism waiting to inherit its legacy either peacefully or with a little bit of last-minute force. Mobilisation and involvement of the broadest layers of the working class in immediate conflict with capitalism, a break with elitism, propagandism, and evolutionism. The integration of the various fronts of the class struggle, ideological, political, economic, into one strategic drive.
The conception of a transitional programme and transitional demands was the product of the great Marxist renaissance and lessons drawn from the terrible collapse in 1914.
Certainly it was part of a world view that saw the struggle for socialism as immediate. But the conception itself, the criticism of the theory and practice of the Second International out of which it came, was a major conquest in understanding the relationship of the daily struggles of the working class to the struggle for socialism, even if the possibility of struggle for socialism were not quite immediate. The Communist International seriously began to discuss transitional demands at about the same time as it accepted that capitalism had survived the post-World-War-One earthquake and reached temporary stabilisation.
Above all the conception of a transitional programme represented a break with the elitist, bureaucratic, evolutionary socialism to which its central core, mass mobilisation in class struggle, is the very antithesis.
Nominal adherence to the method of transitional demands of the Communist International or of the “Transitional Programme” written by Trotsky in 1938 is no guarantee against Second-lnternationalist conceptions. There are no such guarantees. Within nominal adherence, there has been a general reversion in the Trotskyist movement to the level of the Second International. One can even find “Trotskyists” for whom transitional demands are clever devices to manipulate the working class, to con them into socialism; others for whom they are only lists of measures to demand of this or that government; others, again, for whom they are merely propaganda formulas for the literary “exposure” of the reformists; some, indeed, for whom they are semi-religious talismans.
But in history the idea of transitional demands summed up the break with the evolutionary, bureaucratic, elitist conception of socialism. That is what it means for the International-Communist League.
What is an “Action Programme”?
If you attempt to work up a document of answers, slogans, action projects, either you are guided by “inspiration”, pet ideas, or some other arbitrary and subjective approach; or you attempt rigorously to draw practical conclusions from a Marxist analysis of reality and general codifications summing up the experience of the working class so far, focused on the situation facing the British working class.
Your Action Programme will be preceded and accompanied by general propaganda and in depth expositions of the various parts of the Action Programme — otherwise the cadres of the organisation themselves will not understand, or not adequately understand, the Action Programme or some of its sections.
When the 1938 Transitional Programme was produced, a whole background of socialist culture, inside the ranks of the Fourth International and even to a degree on its periphery, could be assumed. The massive debate and the hammering out of such slogans as on the workers’ government by the early Communist International was still living and recent memory (at most 15 to 17 years back) for many of the cadre. Many of the early documents were in their possession or easily available. For example, in the Death Agony of Capitalism and the Tasks of the Fourth lnternational, Trotsky’s exposition of the workers’ government slogan feels no more need of additional warnings of the dangers discussed by the Communist International than to add a summary of the mis-use of the slogan by the Stalinists.
Today, massive lacunae exist in Marxist analysis of society, amounting to a major crisis of Marxism. The weakness of our draft Manifesto in explanation of the condition of capitalism is one illustration of this. Moreover, the general cultural level of the revolutionary movement has been thrown backward massively, to such an extent that perhaps most of the current “Trotskyist” groups could learn valuable positive lessons from the left in the Second International!
Many of the basic concepts used in drafting the Action Programmes of the 30s have lost most of their meaning, or never had any, for the present-day left. Some of them (“Workers’ Control”, “Nationalisation”, “Workers’ Government”) have been given a reformist/utopian character in their current usage. The very conception of socialism itself needs to be restated — for it has simply been perverted into a repulsive elitist “statism” by the dominant sections of the British left.
Many, or most, of the demands essential to an Action Programme have been made into fetish-objects, outside of and above rational judgment and critical and concrete assessment by the “orthodox” Trotskyist sects, because they are part of the Transitional Programme. And even the more flexible “Trotskyists” [Fourth International, UK group Socialist Resistance] who don’t parade the Transitional Programme in ritual procession as Catholics parade statues of Jesus on the feast of Corpus Christi, keep it as an ancestral heirloom in a place of reverence, not quite sure what to do with it, but given to taking chunks of its verbiage to buttress some political monstrosity, whether it be the International Marxist Group’s [forerunner of Socialist Resistance] recent mis-use of the idea of the Socialist United States of Europe. to gain their entry into the ranks of working class chauvinism on the Common Market, or their earlier misuse of the slogan of workers’ control. They are like barbarians who appropriate stones from a once imposing building whose structure has been shattered, to construct hovels for themselves.
And, after the fetishists and their political first cousins, the vandals who believe their hovels are holy because stones from the Transitional Programme cathedral are visibly part of them, come — naturally — the negative fetishists, International Socialism [SWP today].
For them too the Transitional Programme and the method of the Transitional Programme are outside of rational consideration. Irrational rejection is their attitude, with fear as superstitious as the reverence of the Workers Revolutionary Party. They reject in all conditions slogans like the Sliding Scale of Wages, and are entirely confined to the minimum/maximum conception of a programme. The proof of the negative-fetish character of IS’s attitude to the Transitional Programme is that in all their writings and comments, despite all their pretence of cool rationality, they have never rationally assessed the origins, significance, elements, and remaining validity of the 1938 draft. All we have is the true assertion that the demands and slogans in the Transitional Programme were presented in the 1938 document in a setting of brief analysis and all-pervading recognition of chronic capitalist crisis — and, taking off from that, Tony Cliff allowed himself (at the Skegness, rally. 1971) to regale an audience, half of which had never heard of the Transitional Programme, with the idea that if you take it seriously you wind up like Posadas, believing in flying saucers [Juan Posadas was an Argentine Trotskyists who claimed that flying saucers proved the existence of advanced, therefore socialist, societies on other planets].
For all these reasons, explanations, restatement (as on state capitalism versus socialism) and detailed expositions with reference to the history of the slogan (as on the workers’ government) are essential.
“The significance of the programme is the significance of the party” said Trotsky, discussing the Transitional Programme of 1938. For the I-CL [forerunner of AWL] this type of manifesto signifies an attempt to start a process of educating and developing the organisation’s cadres in the politics of the Transitional Programme. The Action Programme element, the slogans and responses, are tools in the hands of the cadres — it is vital that the cadres understand the use, the limits, and relation to the other tools, of each demand. For we do not present or serve up even a much more simple Action Programme in toto: the organisation uses its judgment to decide how to swivel the various elements in the programme so as best to use them in any concrete situation.
Given that framework, there is no reason why we cannot valuably produce a simplified short pamphlet for wider circulation called Action Programme, summarising some elements from the Manifesto and backed up by the Manifesto and other material. But just to present an “Action Programme”, with minimal explanation, would be a bare collection of slogans drawn together mainly from the Transitional Programme. It would be a literary exercise in collation, of not much value.
Alfred Rosmer, in Lenin’s Moscow, reports the comment a communist militant made when Lenin’s pamphlet Left Wing Communism appeared around the time of the Second World Congress of the Communist International in 1920. He said, “It is a dangerous book”, meaning that people would take from it only recipes and licence for artful dodges and “flexibility” of a type altogether different from that which Lenin was trying to teach the ultra-lefts. He was right, of course.
The Transitional Programme of Leon Trotsky is also a “dangerous book” in the epoch when almost the whole political culture of which it was a sort of distillation or “abstract”, designed for a specific purpose, has disappeared. The specific character of the Transitional Programme and even more of the Action Programme for France — lean, honed—down, unintentionally creating an illusion of literary-scientific self-sufficiency, though Trotsky disclaimed anything like that — bears witness to the fact that Trotsky was preparing levers to insert into the labour movement, where a lot could be taken as common ground and the task of the Trotskyist cadres was one of re-orienting the existing movement for action.
It also relates to an immediate situation where the labour movement “switches points” and fights back — or is crushed in the relatively short term. We can operate with no such assumptions. The cadres of so-called “Trotskyism” have largely forgotten or are ignorant of much that the 1938 Trotskyists could take for granted in the mass labour movement they related to in the 1930s (or, at least, did take largely for granted, on pain of otherwise renouncing all hope of re-orienting the movement in time for the coming showdown). Moreover, we operate in a situation of simmering, rather than crushing, crisis.
The Transitional Programme’s slogans have too often been abused, misunderstood, applied in opposition to the spirit of the method of the Transitional Programme — by the French OCI (sect organised by Pierre Lambert) for example, with their “workers’ government” without reference to the state, class mobilisation, or programme in any sense of the word. The same in Ireland where former associates of Workers’ Fight apply what they understand as the Transitional Programme approach to the 26-County Labour Party — and effectively if unintentionally support the coalition government!
In the Middle Ages physicians worked from anatomical textbooks by Galen which they inherited from the ancient world. In a period when it was deemed degrading for such people to do manual work, the doctor would sit in the operating room on a high stool, with Galen’s book open, giving directions to minions and apprentices who actually carried out the operations. Eventually the textbook was discovered to deal not with the anatomy of men and women, but of monkeys! If our former comrades in the League for a Workers’ Republic were to go and study the discussion and documents that produced the slogan and demands in the slim pamphlet they fetishise, they would have to understand that they bear the same sort of relation to Trotsky and the early Comintern and Fourth International as the medieval physicians did to Galen.
How do we use a Manifesto or Action Programme? One of the central theoretical insights of the old Workers’ Fight group [older forerunner of AWL] from its study of the history and problems of the Fourth International was on what a programme is and is not. It is not a blueprint, a fixed document, nor even codifications from experience distilled into directives for action. It is all of these things, but more — a living, fluid interrelation of these with conjunctural analyses and, above all, concrete assessments and responses on the part of the revolutionary organisation. It is a living thing, not a document. It can only live and develop in and through the practice of the revolutionary party — “The significance of the programme is the significance of the party”.
Its revolutionary validity or otherwise is determined not only by whether its theoretical bedrock and basic analysis is sound, but by the other more immediate, more conjunctural factors — that is, all that is spe-cific to the reactions, concrete analysis, and practice of the party. This is where revolutionary Marxism divides from even the best and most useful academic blueprint-making.
Not to understand this is to be open to serious errors — the error of seeing “a document” as “the programme” in itself (the beginning of the process of fetishisation); the error of believing a programme can have revolutionary life apart from the revolutionary party and the working class. (It can have a sort of life, the basic codifications that is, but more like suspended animation, with the risk of “Galenisation” if too long divorced from the practice of a revolutionary organisation or if allowed to flake off from the revivifying struggle for its development as the party develops}. An I-CL Manifesto will be of us to the degree that the I-CL is of use in reacting to and anticipating events — and also in responding creatively to new situations and gaps in the document, of which they were are bound
to be some that we will not detect. Central here is a Marxist detachment and critical spirit. Even if every member of the I-CL agrees with every phrase in the final draft — then especially there can be no fetishisation, no Bordigist complacency about our own products. In 1930 Trotsky acidly replied to the Bordigists who claimed they had “not departed from” their programme of 1925, which in 1925 Trotsky had approved, by pointing out that the purpose of a programme is not “not to be departed from”, but to be used and developed and supplemented as new situations arise, The same comment would do for the present-day “Trotskyists” who claim “not to depart from the Transitional Programme”.
• An article from the preparatory discussion for drafting the manifesto of the I-CL (forerunner of AWL), 1976
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us