Antonin Baudry’s two films about De Gaulle are now showing in cinemas across the UK. The French left-wing newspaper Révolutionnaires reviewed them:
Antonin Baudry’s two films are a box-office hit. Presented as a grand historical epic for families, they have already attracted more than 2 million admissions each. It is true that both films have a certain vigour and feature talented actors. They have been lavished with praise by the entire French political establishment, from [right-winger] Retailleau to [nationalist left] Mélenchon, including Glucksmann [close to the Socialist Party]. Such national unity is enough to arouse a certain degree of suspicion.
The United States as a predatory power
One of the original angles taken by Antonin Baudry is to highlight the role of Roosevelt’s United States, which sought to reshape the world according to its own interests during and after the Second World War. France as it existed in 1940 was in Roosevelt’s sights; for a time, he considered splitting it in two, attaching the north to a greater Wallonia. The film also shows just how unscrupulous the United States was in relying on former Vichy collaborators who were fundamentally antisemitic such as Admiral Darlan, provided that he supplied them with soldiers and did not cause too much trouble. The critique of the aggressiveness of American imperialism resonates with the times we are living in today. This is undoubtedly one of the reasons for the film’s success, including amongst politicians.
A Free France or a Free Empire?
De Gaulle, as played by Simon Abkarian, is a mythical figure who, alone against all odds, is said to have defended the ideal of a France free from the Nazis and independent of the Americans. This is to quickly forget that World -War-2 "Free France" was, above all, a colonial empire that kept millions of people under its rule all over the world. Indeed, the first steps taken by de Gaulle’s collaborators in the film take place in the very heart of Africa – in Cameroon, Chad and the Congo – when General Leclerc arrives to rally part of the colonial administration. The film says nothing about the aspirations for freedom that may have existed within this empire and which were to be widely expressed from 1945 onwards, leading to the massacre by this "Free France" of tens of thousands of Algerians, Indochinese and Malagasy in the years that followed.
Recycling the collaborationist state
Over the course of the two films, which last more than five hours, we see de Gaulle fighting to secure the legitimacy to lead France in the aftermath of the war. Despite other contenders backed by the Americans, he prevails by winning the support of the domestic "Resistance", unified under the leadership of Jean Moulin. The film depicts this race as centring on a national narrative embodied by the providential figure who came to save democracy. One scene in the film nevertheless reveals the underlying stakes of this race: in Algiers, in 1943, the Free French Forces incorporated and rehabilitated gendarmes and police officers who had served the Vichy regime – the very same men who had hunted down Jews and communists. And this was the key role played by de Gaulle: thanks to the legitimacy he had acquired, he managed to restore credibility to the French bourgeois state, which had nevertheless hit rock bottom due to its collaboration with the Nazi regime. In this respect, he embodied a ‘Plan B’ at a time when the bourgeoisie might have feared facing a revolutionary wave, as had happened following the First World War.
Misguided courage
What is nevertheless commendable in the film are the scenes depicting the courage of ordinary people: from young people demonstrating against Nazism beneath the Arc de Triomphe in 1940, to former members of the Spanish International Brigades who joined General Leclerc’s forces, and African soldiers fighting Nazism – even if the film does not give them much of a voice. The determination of this generation to reject fascism is inspiring, even though it was channelled into supporting de Gaulle. Only a revolutionary communist party could have offered broader prospects to this entire generation, in opposition to the colonial empires and to the capitalism that had given rise to fascism.
But the French Communist Party no longer embodied that perspective. The Stalinist bureaucracy had made it endorse the German-Soviet Pact of 1939-41, and then it became one of de Gaulle’s main supporters.
De Gaulle safeguarded the freedom of the French bourgeoisie to continue profiting from the colonial empire without being under the control of American capitalists. The bourgeoisie rewarded him for this role by elevating him to the status of a national hero. Antonin Baudry’s film perpetuates this glorification.
Michel Marteron
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us