Data centres: who owns, who decides?

Data centre

Scotland is being asked to make room for a new industrial revolution. According to Action to Protect Rural Scotland’s Scottish Data Centre Map and campaign materials (APRS, Scottish Data Centre Map), more than twenty proposed data centres are already in the planning system.

The machines are digital, the buildings are enormous, and the sales pitch is familiar: investment, jobs, innovation and prosperity.

Nowhere is that pitch more sharply tested than in North Lanarkshire, where the Scottish Government's first AI Growth Zone is being developed around Airdrie, Chapelhall, Newhouse and the surrounding area.

The Scottish Government says the Lanarkshire AI Growth Zone could bring more than 3,400 jobs, around £8.2 billion of private investment and up to 500MW of computing capacity. The UK Government has presented it as part of Britain's wider AI industrial strategy.

But beneath the language of artificial intelligence lies a much older question: Who owns the infrastructure, who bears its costs, and who decides what it is used for?

In North Lanarkshire DataVita has permission to expand its Chapelhall operation towards 40MW. A larger proposal at South Lanridge/Newhouse could reach 500MW, while ILI has proposed a potential 400MW data centre on Green Belt land at Newhouse.

DataVita also submitted a planning application for its 120MW DV4 facility at Chapelhall in September 2026, supported by assessments covering energy, decarbonisation, noise, air quality, transport, drainage, ecology, landscape and economic impact.

But, following the Scottish Government's September announcement, developments above 50MW are now subject to mandatory Environmental Impact Assessment requirements.

That change is welcome, but it raises a broader question: Why should communities discover the consequences of an industrial transformation only after the investment model has been chosen?

The Scottish Parliament's Climate Action Committee is investigating the environmental impacts of hyperscale data centres, including effects on water, air quality, biodiversity, soils, noise, energy use and emissions, with evidence sessions due in October and November 2026

Scotland has renewable electricity, fibre connectivity, universities and a growing technology sector. Attracting investment in future industries is a legitimate argument.

But a data centre also makes a long-term claim on electricity capacity, grid infrastructure, water, roads, construction materials and skilled labour. The Scottish Government's own work acknowledges that AI and data centres raise questions about energy, water, resources and emissions

The Government says the Lanarkshire project could generate £540 million in community investment over 15 years. That figure requires scrutiny. Communities should know how it is calculated, who controls it, what conditions apply and how it compares with the value of the infrastructure and resources being committed.

The central Socialist question is therefore one of social ownership and clear, positive local benefits.

If enormous quantities of Scottish electricity are allocated to private computing infrastructure, what do working-class people receive in return? If land is converted into industrial infrastructure, what does the surrounding community gain?

If billions in private capital are attracted, how much remains locally? And if public authorities provide roads, grid connections, planning capacity, training or tax advantages, where is the corresponding public ownership?

A data centre may have a relatively low operational carbon footprint if it uses renewable electricity. But AI does not begin at the substation.

The computers require servers, GPUs, networking equipment, batteries, transformers, cooling systems, steel, concrete, copper and semiconductors.

AI is a physical industrial system involving data centres, electricity networks, water, land, hardware and critical-mineral supply chains. Its environmental footprint cannot be measured by the electricity consumed by the finished computer alone.

The International Energy Agency has warned that demand for critical minerals creates environmental and social pressures around mining and processing, including impacts on water, biodiversity, human rights and communities.

Scotland could therefore celebrate a “green” data centre while displacing environmental costs elsewhere. A genuinely internationalist environmental movement must ask not only whether the electricity is renewable, but what the complete material footprint of the computing economy is and which workers and communities pay for it.

Data-centre campaigns often focus on planning, landscape and electricity. A socialist critique must also ask who builds the facilities, manufactures the hardware, mines the minerals, maintains the servers, cleans and secures the buildings, manages logistics and performs the invisible digital labour that makes AI possible.

The Scottish Government's headline figure of 3,400 jobs therefore tells us little without answers to basic questions:

How many are permanent, local, directly employed and unionised? How many are construction, outsourced or highly paid technical roles? What collective-bargaining arrangements will apply? What minimum employment standards will accompany public support?

These are not anti-technology questions. They are pro-worker questions.

The International Labour Organization has warned that AI affects not only job numbers but also job quality, algorithmic management and working conditions throughout AI value chains. Its research stresses the importance of worker representation and social dialogue.

The contradiction is that AI infrastructure is presented as a source of employment while AI is also expected to transform work across the economy. The ILO's 2025 research estimates that roughly one in four workers globally are in occupations exposed to generative AI, while stressing that transformation is generally more likely than outright redundancy.

The question for North Lanarkshire is therefore not only how many jobs data centres create, but how the computing power they provide may affect employment elsewhere.

Workers need collective bargaining rights over AI deployment, consultation over automation, retraining rights, protection from algorithmic surveillance and a genuine say in how technology changes the workplace.

AI and large-scale computing could give employers increasingly powerful tools for monitoring, scheduling, measuring and managing workers. The ILO identifies algorithmic management as an emerging workplace issue.

Without democratic safeguards, technology that could improve working conditions could instead intensify work and shift productivity gains towards capital. The same question applies to public-sector, military, policing and immigration uses.

The UK Government is digitising immigration and border systems through eVisas and Electronic Travel Authorisations, while maintaining extensive datasets across Border Force, UK Visas and Immigration, and Immigration Enforcement.

The Government also announced a strategic partnership with Palantir in 2025, including AI-powered military capabilities and up to £1.5 billion of UK investment. Palantir software is already used across defence and has attracted controversy through its work with governments, military agencies and immigration authorities.

There is currently no evidence that the Lanarkshire AI Growth Zone is contracted for immigration enforcement, military AI or Palantir facilities. That distinction matters. But if public money, Scottish land and Scottish energy help create strategically important computing infrastructure, citizens should know what uses it can support.

Communities should be able to ask:

Which companies, governments and public agencies can purchase computing capacity? Can facilities support military AI, immigration enforcement or predictive policing? What safeguards apply to personal data? What international military or surveillance uses are permitted? Can workers or communities object to particular uses?

Scotland risks reproducing a familiar colonial economic pattern in digital form: infrastructure and profits are concentrated in wealthy countries, while raw materials, manufacturing, environmental damage and labour costs are distributed across global supply chains.

The strongest argument against an uncontrolled data-centre boom is therefore not simply “don’t build it here”, but “don’t build an exploitative global computing system anywhere.”

Scotland's renewable energy, universities, engineering expertise and digital infrastructure could serve a legitimate public purpose, but the alternative should be public-interest computing, not simply corporate computing.

That requires:

• Public or community ownership: Strategic computing infrastructure should be democratically governed and subject to public-interest obligations.

• Genuine community benefit: Benefits must be substantial, transparent, enforceable and controlled with meaningful local participation.

• Trade-union guarantees: Publicly supported facilities should recognise unions, protect collective bargaining and give workers representation over AI and automation.

• Transparency over use: Citizens should know who is buying computing capacity and whether it supports military, policing, immigration or surveillance activity.

• Full lifecycle environmental accounting: Planning must include construction emissions, hardware, minerals, water, batteries, backup generation, waste and international supply chains.

• Global labour standards: Procurement should require demonstrable labour and human-rights protections throughout the supply chain.

• Democratic control: Workers and working-class communities should help decide who owns, controls and uses facilities consuming hundreds of megawatts.

Renewable electricity is essential, but it is not impact-free. Large industrial loads can still require major grid investment and place pressure on scarce resources.

The debate is often framed as a choice between being “pro-business” and “anti-progress”. That is false. The real question is whether digital industrialisation will serve capital or be shaped by democratic, environmental and social priorities.

North Lanarkshire has experienced industrialisation and deindustrialisation before. Its communities know what happens when governments and companies promise prosperity while distributing costs and benefits unequally.

The new industrial landscape looks different, but the political questions remain familiar: Who owns it? Who controls it? Who works for it? Who profits from it? And who pays when things go wrong?

Scottish people should not reject technology. They should reject the idea that technological progress requires democratic surrender. If North Lanarkshire is to become a centre of AI, its people should have a decisive say not only over where the buildings go, but over what kind of economy they create.

Campaigning organisations and resources:

For comrades who want to find out more about campaigns against hyperscale data centres in Scotland:

Action to Protect Rural Scotland (APRS) — national campaign and information on hyperscale data-centre proposals (APRS).

Environmental Rights Centre Scotland (ERCS) — environmental-law and planning work connected with data-centre proposals and community campaigns (ERCS).

Scottish Parliament Petition PE2233 — calling for a moratorium on hyperscale data-centre planning applications until their environmental impacts have been assessed (Petition PE2233).

Comments?
We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.