What is the current state of trans health care in Wales?
While still inadequate, the healthcare pathway for Welsh trans people was formerly the best in the UK. With an approximately two year waiting list for first appointments, the Welsh Gender Service professionally explored patient history and didn't pathologise the patient’s transgender status or dissuade them from transitioning. If surgery was appropriate and the risks had been covered and accepted, a patient could then be referred for a second review in England before finally being referred to a clinic in London, Brighton, or Manchester. A huge point of contention within the Welsh trans community is the reliance on English clinics for our surgeries - while NHS Wales is devolved, our clinical pathway is dependent on a neighbouring, more restrictive country over which we have next to no democratic input.
Every other aspect of gender affirming healthcare is still possible in Wales, but the NWJCC (NHS Wales Joint Commissioning Committee) decision to suspend all gender affirming surgeries with no evidence to justify their intervention is unprecedented. With their bodily autonomy denied, the entire Welsh trans community is in crisis. A review is yet to begin and the community has been left in limbo. The Welsh trans community cynically but understandably assumes that if an independent review will ever be commenced, it will have as many methodological flaws and biases as the Cass Review, manufacturing consent for further restrictions on trans healthcare.
What kind of response has there been? What have you and others been doing in Cardiff and elsewhere?
This has been met with uproar in the Welsh trans community. With only three days’ notice, a demonstration attracting 300 people was held. Mutual aid networks organised to raise funds to support those whose surgeries had been cancelled. Writing campaigns have started. Grassroots movements have begun to take form, guided by a principle of forming a decentralised united front for trans liberation. The movement is still young, but there are also efforts to replicate and expand responses in Cardiff for the communities of North Wales.
What kind of support has the campaign received so far? From unions, from other campaign groups?
Unfortunately we have received very little in the way of direct support. Welsh LGBTQ+ orgs and grassroots movements have been on the front lines contacting members of the Senedd, the NWJCC, and Welsh NHS to gather more information. Mutual aid networks like Trans Aid Cymru have been organising fundraising campaigns to recompensate those whose surgeries had been cancelled. UK-wide trans orgs have released statements and have directed people to the email addresses of people to message. However, the trade unions continue their long and disappointing history of dragging their feet on solidarity with the LGBTQ+ community. As of writing this, only the NUS submitted a statement of solidarity. A draft has been submitted to PCS Wales, but the Welsh Executive Committee objected to it due to the political nature of the proposed action points. There are few groups willing to say anything and even fewer willing to actually do anything to help us.
What are the plans going forward?
Due to the decentralised nature of this resistance, it is hard to tell. Some are pursuing the legal route of cornering the NWJCC on its malpractice and violation of its own legislation, forcing the Plaid Cymru government to finally acknowledge the corruption and intervene. Others are preparing more demonstrations to keep momentum up and encourage more people meet each other to bolster the networks of organisation. Others still continuously write to keep the pressure up and to encourage the unions to finally get involved. Generally, all groups involved are keeping the pressure high and surrounding the institutional bodies from all angles until they have no choice but to admit wrongdoing.
But this won't be the end.
This scandal has hurt many trans people and our allies in personal ways never before felt. It has bred a revolutionary spirit within the community, including among those who had never before protested in their life, which has potential. The dire and oppressive conditions placed upon the trans community are like a powder keg, and among the Welsh trans community, this has caused a spark which has potential to erupt into a bright and powerful flame of class consciousness.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us