Ukraine is fighting to defend itself against Russian imperialist aggression and occupation. In 2024 Russian forces took a staggering 420,000 casualties and Ukraine destroyed 3,000 Russian tanks and 9,000 armoured vehicles.
Nevertheless, Russia’s economic clout and relative size, combined with President Vladimir Putin’s ruthless and cruel leadership, meant that it continued to grind forward on Ukraine’s Donbas front. Russia gained 4,200 sq km of territory in 2024.
Russia continues to advance in eastern Ukraine, now threatening to overrun the towns of Kreminna, Toretsk, Pokrovsk and Kurakhove. Russia has pulverised Ukraine’s energy infrastructure, hoping to demoralise the civilian population.
Ukraine has not only been the victim of Russian power, but has also been hampered by a deliberately weak response from the US administration and the Western European states. American President Joe Biden has sought to give Ukraine enough weapons not to lose to Russia, but not enough to push the Russian occupiers out of the country.
That policy has failed and seems about to end.
The danger now for Ukraine is that a US administration under Donald Trump will force Ukraine into a lousy peace deal. Trump has spoken about his admiration for Putin.
Ukraine, a relatively weak and poor country, has been bullied by Western powers before. In 2015, following the Russian annexation of Crimea in 2014, Germany and France forced Ukraine to sign up to pro-Russia treaties, Minsk 1 and 2, which substantially impacted on Ukraine’s right to self-determination.
France and Germany wanted to reestablish peaceful and profitable relations with Putin’s Russia, and were willing to sacrifice Ukraine’s rights to do so.
The agreements signed in 2015 led to a simmering war in Donbas and allowed Putin time to prepare for the full-scale invasion of February 2022.
A botched, Putin-friendly, peace in 2025 may well allow Russia to continue its aggressive actions against Moldova, Georgia and in the Baltic, as well as prepare the way for a future war in Ukraine.
Benefits
Trump might hope for economic benefits from an agreement with Putin and which is forced on Ukraine by denying Ukraine the weapons and financial aid it needs to defend itself.
According to Ukrainian media Russia’s envoy to the UN, Vasily Nebenzya, dismissed an approach from Trump’s representatives to end the war as “vague”. Trump appears to have proposed that Ukraine’s membership of NATO be delayed for decades, while European peacekeepers monitor a ceasefire in Ukraine.
Nebenzya said Russia was opposed to a freeze in the conflict. Russia flatly opposes Ukraine’s membership of NATO and wants the four Ukrainian regions of Luhansk, Donetsk Zaporizhzhia and Kherson ceded to Russia, including the areas currently under Ukrainian control.
This falls short of Putin’s stated objective of abolishing Ukraine, which he denies has the right to exist.
In September Trump’s future Vice President, J D Vance, who is hostile to Ukraine’s rights, said the current battlelines would become a demilitarised zone, fortified so that Russia would not invade again. The Wall Street Journal reported that the demilitarised zone would be 1,300km long and be policed by European troops.
Vance has declared that he “did not really care what happens to Ukraine.”
Ukrainian officials have been lobbying Trump, flattering and praising him to try to get some political advantage. Oleksandr Merezhko, chair of Ukraine’s foreign affairs committee, has even nominated Trump for the Nobel peace prize.
The latest polling data from Ukraine suggests that there is still a narrow majority (51%) for refusing any peace with Russia which requires territorial concessions. 38% would accept peace in return for territorial concessions (in 2022 the figures were 85 to 10%).
On 27 November Trump appointed former US general Keith Kellogg as his special envoy to deal with the Ukraine-Russia war. Last April Kellogg produced a paper in which he argued the US could continue to support Ukraine with military aid as long as Ukraine agreed to participate in peace talks; Russia would be offered some sanctions relief if it joined peace discussions.
The Russian economy appears to be under strain. This year’s growth forecast is under 1%, inflation is around 10% and there are serious labour shortages in many industries.
Kellogg recently condemned the assassination of Russian general Igor Kirillov in Moscow while also opposing Russian drone and missile attacks on Ukrainian cities. However, the killing of a Russian general and the deliberate, systematic destroying of civilian electricity supplies in Ukraine are not equivalent.
Kirillov was a central figure responsible for Russian chemical, nuclear and biological warfare and a legitimate target for a state fighting for the survival of their nation. The destruction of essential civilian infrastructure is a war crime.
Workers’ Liberty and the internationalist socialist left will continue to demand an end to the war on the basis of the unconditional withdrawal of Russian armed forces from occupied areas of Ukraine.
We demand the West gives weapons and financial aid in sufficient quantities, promptly, so that Ukraine can defend itself.
If Ukraine is forced by a Trump-led US to sign a poor deal with Russia in order to avoid even worse consequences we will not necessarily criticise Ukraine. But it is down to Ukraine, and only Ukraine, to decide, not the US or other big powers.
Victory to Ukraine! For the Ukrainian working class!
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us