Biden: downplaying the “evil” in “lesser evil”

I voted stickers

In our debate on the US election, Katy Dollar, Simon Nelson and co. have argued that advocating a Biden vote, as the least-bad option open to US workers on 5 November, must inevitably result in political illusions and disorientation. I did not and do not believe that is inevitable. But Claureen Ryan and Wesley Harding for the “vote Biden” camp seem to be doing their damndest to furnish Dollar and Nelson with evidence.

It is a criminal failure by the left that there will not be even a half-decent challenger for working-class politics on the ballot, as Howie Hawkins was in 2020. Given that failure on the electoral front, the main focus of socialists must be to urge organisation and struggles on the other fronts available to workers now, and building an independent working-class force for future contests. These will be necessary for whoever wins this election to confront both the next presidency and the underlying politics of Trumpism.

Within that context, and as a strictly secondary priority, it is honest and realistic for socialists to acknowledge openly that voting Biden, in hopes of holding off Trump, is the least-bad option available to workers on 5 November.

But that does not permit underplaying or resisting a frank assessment of the Democratic Party and the condition and norms of Democrat-Republican bourgeois politics beyond and before Trump. Yet that is what Ryan and Harding’s recent contributions do (Solidarity 710, 712, 713, 714).

Take, for example, Ryan’s warning that “the Republican Party, where it has local power, is changing voting laws to make it more difficult for Black people to vote”. This will hardly come as news to Black (and Latino, poorer, etc) people in the US. Trump-era attacks on their ability to vote, and to have that vote matter, are not novel. They stepped up a pre-existing wave of disenfranchisement, suppression and gerrymandering.

Attacks on voting rights, especially against Black people, never completely went away in the US, but it is true that there has been a renewed onslaught. But accounts of this history, such as David Daley’s in the New Republic, show that this new assault on voting power (via gerrymandering) and voting rights (suppression measures including skewed ID requirements, electoral roll purges, closing polling stations, obstructions to registration, poll taxes etc) preceded both Trump and the influx of Tea Party politicians that teed him up.

Their more “respectable” Republican antecedents – Harding’s “normal bourgeois politicians” –consciously cooked up and committed to a strategy for anti-democratic minority rule (e.g. the 2010 REDMAP gerrymandering initiative). Daley shows – including via admissions by Republican officials from the period who have turned against Trump – that the Trumpists did not invent this but, in some ways, the opposite: it let the proto-Trumpists in, who then embraced and escalated it.

Similarly, Dollar is correct to argue that many of Ryan’s other warnings about Trump are not new or unique. She shows clearly that, for example, winning elections via sheer spending power and against the popular vote, are not preserves of Trump and his Trumpified party. Nelson highlights the fact that Obama oversaw more deportations of undocumented migrants in 2012 than Trump did in his entire presidency. At our conference, some comrades spoke as if they thought armed police presence on US university campuses and even in schools was a new development associated with Trumpism, rather than the long-standing violent norm it is.

Meanwhile, Ryan gives a skewed picture of Biden’s labour credentials by highlighting his visit to a car factory workers’ picket line, while omitting his suppression of the rail workers’ strike over sick pay.

Clarity on all this matters not only for accurate understanding and maintaining a wider perspective, but also our basic credibility. If, as Ryan does, socialists speak as if we have only just woken up to anti-democratic, racist and reactionary trends and frame them as so exceptional to Trump and Trumpism – if for the sake of putting Trump into contrast, we downplay or recoil from applying critiques more broadly – then socialists can only appear detached, ill-informed and unpersuasive to any listener familiar with the facts, and miseducate those not yet informed.

Yet Harding responds to accurate critiques with the accusation that Dollar “seems to suggest there’s no significant political difference between Biden and Trump for anyone to be bothered about”. False: Dollar clearly identifies a key difference that makes Trump particularly dangerous: the “large and militant collection of right-wing forces” that follow him. It is as if, for Harding, merely contextualising Trumpism and critiquing the Democrats cancels out criticism of Trump as worse, amounting to unacceptable equivocation.

The degree to which Ryan leans on the US courts is also worrying. It is indeed good that the NY court was not too cowed to correctly find Trump guilty of fraud in his electoral “hush money” trial. It is bad that he has been able to delay other cases. We want to see electoral fraud caught and dealt with. But Ryan says the problem here is that the delays deprive voters of “vital information”. It cannot be the approach of class struggle socialists to preach such reliance on the US justice system – which came to the right conclusion against Trump but which has also fitted-up so many Black and working-class militants before and will surely try again – as an authoritative source of political information.

Ryan is also outraged that the Supreme Court’s interpretation of insurrection laws prevented individual states removing Trump from the ballot. Even the liberal judges agreed that allowing individual state governments (themselves also partisan) to make such decisions could create a chaotic patchwork and not a stronger democracy. Does Ryan not at least pause to consider that a looser interpretation of these laws might also be turned against socialists, or even against any official or office-holder decent enough to refuse dangerous and anti-democratic orders issued by a future Trump/Trumpist presidency?

We must surely be able to “walk and chew gum” at the same time. Ryan and Harding’s apparent refusal to do so is perplexing. Acknowledging Biden as a genuinely lesser evil is not a licence to downplay or recoil from reasonable critique and context concerning him and the Democrats. It does not permit presenting Trump and Trumpism ahistorically, disconnecting them from wider and pre-existing anti-democratic phenomena in bourgeois US politics. It does not require us to preach such reliance on the existing state to regulate politics.

Dollar and co. are wrong to suggest that socialists should not answer the question of what US workers should do at the polling station on 5 November. We should not resign ourselves to the idea that giving a straightforward answer to that question can only result in submerging our wider programme and disorienting ourselves and other workers. But Ryan and Harding provide a poor example.

Comments?
We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.