I experienced five general secretaries of my union (NUR, then RMT) during my career on the railway. Another is coming up shortly, if rumours are to be believed.
The first was Sid Weighell (1975-83), without doubt the most mendacious of them all. His sole aim in life was to keep the old Communist Party from taking control of “his” union. No trick was too underhand to use, especially obscure rules from the union rule book.
He defied the National Executive on many occasions, with the connivance of the senior assistant general secretary, Vernon Hince, who was lining himself up to take over from Sid when he retired or more likely died in service.
They kept control until 1982 when the first national strike of the NUR took place before dear old Sid managed to get the national conference to call it off, bypassing the National Executive. At that time the NUR was nowhere near a democratic, member-led union.
Sid’s downfall came about in 1983 when at TUC congress he cast a vote against the express wishes of the delegation. He first denied it. Over a period of time and some detective work, it was proved beyond a shadow of a doubt.
He wangled a special recall conference to discuss the affair, and expected the conference to refuse to accept an offer from him to resign — effectively, to pardon his actions. We, the left in the union, no longer dominated by the CP, managed to mobilise. The vote while close, but accepted his resignation. Off he went, murmuring about left-wing conspiracies.
The next General Secretary was Jimmy Knapp (1983-2001). A genial sort of person, he was regarded as a stopgap compromise between Charlie Turnock, preferred by the old bureaucracy, and some one more radical, a sort of NUR version of Arthur Scargill minus the Stalinoid tendencies. We could not get agreement on who that was so we compromised on supporting Jimmy Knapp.
Knapp was actually in office for 18 years, during which time the railway started changing. Supporting the miners during the 1984-5 strike with a boycott of scab coal, the signallers had the support of the union leadership as far as that went. But action was left up to individual signallers, as the union did not want to run foul of the anti-trade-union laws.
The biggest let down was not co-ordinating with the NUM and not calling for a strike over the closure of the pits which would have directly led to redundancies on the railway and coal no longer being transported by rail.
The next layer of bureaucracy inside the union was still the old gang from Sid Weighell’s time and Jimmy Knapp never took that on board. His tenure was hamstrung by that, and he was unwilling to get help from the left in the union.
Some strikes were called over pay with some success but the biggest fight — against privatisation — was dodged with the argument that action would be a “political strike”, banned by the anti-trade-union laws. A lobbying campaign was launched but had little impact.
Knapp died while in office in 2001, his name indelibly linked with that failed fight against privatisation of the railway. More on the other three later.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us