The road to Bolshevism: Plekhanov as “the father of Russian Marxism?

plekhanov

In the competition between Narodnaya Volya and Black Redistribution after 1879, immediate success was all, and all-important. In terms of practical activity, Black Redistribution could do nothing. Its members either fell into inactivity, or defected to Narodnaya Volya. There was historical justice in that, because, as Plekhanov would later stress, Narodnaya Volya had moved ahead of them in the necessary turn to politics.

The killing of the Tsar in 1881 did not unleash mass revolution, as some of them had hoped, or even reform. It unleashed a decade of mass reaction and repression. Six Narodnaya Volya members were condemned for killing the Tsar, two of them women. Five were hanged. The sixth, Gesya Helfman, was held from the gallows so that she could give birth to the baby she was carrying. Immediately afterwards she died in jail, perhaps with help.

After the killing of the Tsar, the executive of Narodnaya Volya wrote an open letter to the new Tsar in which they made only two demands on him:

(1) A general amnesty for all “political criminals”

(2) The summoning of representatives of all the Russian people “in order to reconsider the existing system of the State and social life”.

Its “moderation” won it the sympathy of “liberal society” in Russia and abroad. It was also a measure of how they had moved from the socialist programme of ZiV — and indeed from their own programme. They now, despite what the 1879 programme had said about leaning on the people, aligned mostly with their natural political allies, the bourgeoisie and the liberal aristocrats.

After 1881, Narodnaya Volya continued to exist and published a journal in exile, but the repression had essentially smashed the group.

In all this, Black Redistribution and its leaders had been politically marginalised. They expressed support for Narodnaya Volya and solidarised with its militants. So, as we saw, did Karl Marx.

They moved only slowly on to the new political ground which they had rejected on principle in 1879 — and towards the foundation of the first non-populist, consistent, Marxist movement in Russia, the Group for the Emancipation of Labour, in September 1883.

Central to the group’s theoretical evolution was the existence of a strong working-class movement in Europe and the new and growing working class in Russia. Although politically it was still entwined with a populist movement, the Russian proletariat had already taken action as a distinct class and incipiently as a distinct political force.

[1] This would later be focused as the Russian bourgeois demand for something like Britain’s “supplementary revolution” (the “Glorious Revolution” of 1688, after the civil war period from 1642 to 1649, when the King was beheaded), which gave the bourgeoisie much of what in that age distinguished its wants from the old absolute monarchy: habeas corpus, end of pre-publication censorship, right of free speech, etc.

[2] The question of all or most land to the peasants divided the Left Social Revolutionaries and the Bolshevik Party in 1918, and led to the beginning of the civil war.

[3] As we were “supportive” of the IRA in the 1970s, though we would never have voted to do what they were doing, and sometimes, as with the Belfast “Bloody Friday” bombings of 21 July 1972 and the Birmingham pub bombings of 21 November 1974, had to dissociate pointedly from what they did. They were in rebellion against the artificial partition of Ireland. In Ireland there was a natural (Catholic) majority and a natural (Protestant) minority. The given partion created a second, artificial minority (Catholic) in the Six Counties. We disagreed with the IRA’s approach, but, living in Britain, we could not make that disagreement the all-determining thing.

[4] Hal Draper revived this above-below dichotomy and counterposed “socialism from below” to the “socialism (that is, liberal Stalinism) from above” of Isaac Deutscher and of the Orthodox Trotskyists who gave “critical support” to the regimes imposed by the Russian army in Eastern Europe. It thus had a use, and was less organically anarchist. But all revolutions, by definition, are from below — including even the bureaucratic revolutions by the independent Stalinist movements, in Yugoslavia, China, Cuba, Vietnam.

[5] The Orthodox Trotskyists influenced by Ted Grant argued that the reason for the the creation of “deformed workers’ states” in Eastern Europe, China, etc. was a spontaneous economic trend. Any human agency would do, not only the Stalinists. Grant thought that what he called “the autonomous movement of the productive forces”, the impatience so to speak of the “productive forces” with what Trotsky called “the crisis of leadership”, had a lot to do with the appearance of what Grant and others called deformed workers’ states. They thought Syria and Burma had become deformed workers’ states by the mid 1960s.

Timeline

June 1879: the revolutionary populist group Zemlya i Volya (Land and Freedom) splits. The majority forms Narodnaya Volya (NV, People’s Will). Plekhanov leads the minority, Chornyi Peredel (BR, Black Redistribution).

1879-81: Black Redistribution never really gets going. Plekhanov and his close comrades flee to exile in Switzerland. NV gains support.

March 1881: NV kills Tsar Alexander II, the “Liberator” who had freed the serfs. The new Tsar is markedly more illiberal than his father was; the result is not democratic reform, but increased repression, which quells NV (and the incipient workers’ movement too).

April 1881: The beginning of large-scale antisemitic pogroms and the movement west of Russian Jews. NV welcomes the pogroms as a manifestation of “the people”. BR criticises NV.

September 1883: Plekhanov and his comrades found the Group for the Emancipation of Labour, in exile

Early 1885: Plekhanov publishes his major book Our Differences

1891: Famine in Russian empire. The movement in society to deal with it is the turning of the tide for the recovery of society from the repression that followed the killing of the Tsar in 1881.

Early 1890s: Workers’ movement in Russia, and Marxist groups on Plekhanov’s lines, appear after a decade of isolation for Plekhanov and his comrades.

1894:On Agitation, by Julius Martov and Arkadi Kremer, appears.

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.