Report after report has pointed to a rapid rise in rents for students, and poor levels of maintenance.
Universities have added to the housing crisis, with a move to private providers rather than in-house accommodation, so direct control over rents is removed. In any case, university-owned accommodation rents have risen more than maintenance support.
A report from the Higher Education Policy Institute (HEPI) on ten university cities found rents up 14.6% 2021-22 to 2023-4, and private sector rents up 19%. Meanwhile the maximum student maintenance loan in England rose 5.2%. In 2023-4 in England, the average rent of £7,566 will take up nearly 100% of the average loan received and 76 per cent of the maximum loan.
The combination creates a vicious circle of misery for students. Other reports show that student mental health is at an all-time low, with financial burdens as a leading cause.
The current model of funding is broken. It means students from the most disadvantaged backgrounds coming out of higher education with the highest levels of debt, and those from middling and better-off backgrounds relying on support from parents.
The cut off point for the maximum maintenance loan in England is low. So students rely on other borrowing, parental support, or work for more than 18 hours a week, just to pay rent and living costs.
The report is explicit about blame: “The student maintenance system needs resetting”. Poor regulation of the housing market and the privatisation of student accommodation make things worse.
The report makes some good recommendations, but with woolly suggestions like advice to students and awareness, plus calls for maintenance to increase to cover higher rents rather rents to be lowered and for more use of bursaries or hardship funds rather than a system providing for all.
Its suggestion that maintenance loans need to be “based on what it actually costs to be a student” do not go far enough. A maintenance system based on loans is a lifelong barrier to students from disadvantaged backgrounds and offers nothing to international students.
In the UK there are four different systems of funding for higher education. The tiered system in Wales seeks to balance between maintenance and loans. It would be an improvement for English students, but still doesn’t go far enough.
We need to see the abolition of loans, replaced with grants at the level of a real living wage for all.
For that we need to build strong campaigns in student unions, in the National Union of Students (NUS) and in the wider labour movement. Low levels of financial support coupled with high levels of tuition fees, and all via loans, are a barrier to working-class young people and even more to those in work who want to re-educate themselves.
Current NUS policy is weak and confused. We need to get organised, for NUS and the wider student movement to take up demands to fix higher education and in coordination with the wider labour movement to build the necessary political pressure.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us