Two national peoples, one historically colonially subjugated by the state of the other. An ongoing war of attempted conquest and occupation. Devastating air strikes, bombardment of civilian targets, cutting off access to utilities and humanitarian aid. An authoritarian leader who continually denies the legitimacy of the subjugated people’s national identity and right to self-determination.
Israel/Palestine, Russia/Ukraine, Putin/Netanyahu. There are many clear similarities between these two situations.
As Ukrainian activist and writer Daria Saburova put it, “How can we look at images of Gaza and not see Mariupol or Bakhmut?” Those who oppose Russia’s war and support Ukraine’s right to self-determination should oppose Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and its blockade and current siege of Gaza, and support the Palestinian people’s right to their own state.
Workers’ Liberty has been the most vocal and explicit of any current on the UK far left in backing Ukraine’s war of national self-defence against attempted Russian conquest. We back that war not because we politically support the Ukrainian government or state in a more general sense, but because we support what would be the immediate outcome of a Ukrainian victory: the protection of Ukraine’s national self-determination.
When Hamas launched its attacks against Israel on 7 October, several commentators on the UK and international left immediately drew comparisons with Ukraine, arguing that those who supported Ukraine’s military resistance to Russian occupation should support (what they saw as) Hamas’s military resistance to Israeli occupation.
Socialists should support Palestinians’ right to resist. That includes the right to take up arms against the occupying military, and to defend themselves against military attack. But that general principle does not imply endorsement for all actions undertaken in the name of “resistance”, by no-matter-what political force.
Young people at a music festival, elderly men and women, and tiny children are not an occupying military. And Hamas is not fighting to win Palestinian self-determination on an equal basis to Israeli Jews (i.e., two states with equal rights). Its aim is for a theocratic state in all of pre-1948 Palestine, purged of Jews.
An analogy would arise if a far-right Ukrainian militia was conducting incursions into Russia itself, slaughtering Russian civilians, taking Russian civilian hostages, all on the basis of a political programme explicitly advocating the destruction of Russia. There is no such situation in Ukraine, nor any prospect of one — but if there was, there is no socialist or anti-imperialist principle that could possibly justify support for it.
These views are often met with the retort that non-Palestinians have no right to “tell Palestinians how to resist”. But by refusing to oppose Hamas, socialists are not somehow “remaining neutral” on the question of “how Palestinians should resist”, but endorsing the efforts of one current — one of the most reactionary in Palestinian society — to make its “resistance” the dominant one. What about the many Palestinians who oppose Hamas, who advocate a different kind of “resistance”, on a different political basis?
Ultimately this approach represents an abstention from politics. What “right” does anyone really have to “tell” anyone anything? Opposing Hamas, and instead supporting the political approaches advocated by Palestinian socialists such as Ayman Odeh, is not about “telling Palestinians what to do”, but about applying our politics in a consistent, rather than relativistic and conditional, way.
There is surely a political opportunity to make links between the Ukrainian and Palestinian struggles — and not just these, but also the struggles of other peoples fighting for the win or retain their right to self-determination: Kurds, Uyghurs, Tibetans, Hong Kongers, Taiwanese, West Papuans, Saharawis, Chechens, and others. But those linkages, if they are to help advance socialist politics, have to be made on the basis of consistent democracy, the advocacy of equal democratic rights for all peoples. Misleading comparisons, based on a fetishisation of any military resistance, even for reactionary aims, serve no-one’s struggles.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us