"Put fossil fuel industry under public ownership and run it in reverse"

Holly Jean Buck has emerged in recent years as one of the most incisive voices on the left on climate change, notably with After Geoengineering (2019), along with a range of academic and popular articles. Her recent book, Ending Fossil Fuels: Why Net Zero Is Not Enough (2021) is another valuable contribution, confronting realities, facing difficult questions and drawing out serious, grounded political conclusions that take the struggle forward.

Fossil fuel realities

The first merit of the book is to underline the power of the fossil fuel industry and the scale of what has to be ended. Fossil fuels still provide more than 84% of primary energy. There are 7,604 coal-fired power plants operating, under construction or proposed around the world.

Millions of people work in the fossil fuel industry. In the United States, oil and gas employs around 603,000 and 271,000 respectively, with coal jobs about 75,000. About 770 million people in the world have no access to electricity and 2.6 billion don’t have access to energy for clean cooking.

Governments give fossil fuels about twice the level of support they do to renewables. Supporting fossil fuels costs governments between US$300 and $600 billion per year, according to the OECD and the International Energy Agency.

Over half of global oil production, and even more than that of reserves, are owned by national oil companies fully or majority-owned by governments: Petrobras, Sinopec, National Iranian Oil Company and Pemex. Major private firms are Shell, BP, Exxon, Chevron and Total. There are one billion cars on the road. The average age of a car is 7-8 years, with a lifetime of 15 years.

Over half the world’s least developed countries plan to expand fossil fuel production as a lever for economic development. US production of oil and gas increased dramatically because of the shale revolution. Buck sums up the situation starkly:

“Ending fossil fuels demands navigating the risk of energy poverty if replacements don’t come online fast enough, the dependence of governments on fossil fuel revenues, and the dependence of communities and households on fossil fuel jobs. On top of these fundamental challenges, there are also two other unsettling scenarios for this decade that may complicate any planned phaseout. One scenario is a coming disenchantment with renewables. The other is the arrival of low-carbon fossil fuels. Both of these prospects will make it extremely hard to completely end fossil fuels.”

Renewables

Renewables are the obvious alternative to the fossil fuel industry. Renewables are growing fast, but wind, solar, and biofuels provide just 5% of global primary energy, hydro 6% and nuclear 4%. In the United States, solar employs about 240,000 and wind 120,000.

The Princeton report, Net-Zero America: Potential Pathways, Infrastructure, and Impacts (2021) sets out plans to phase out the fossil fuel industry by 2030. Seven hundred coal mines would close and 500 coal-fired power plants retired. Oil and gas production decrease. Half a million gas wells close.

In the Princeton scenario, wind and solar farms span an area of 1 million km. This is equivalent to the combined land areas of Arkansas, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, Nebraska, and Oklahoma – or an area roughly the size of France and Spain. (This is all land visually impacted by wind turbines, not where the turbine pad directly sits). Land for solar is equivalent to the size of West Virginia or an area about half the size of England. The entire Atlantic Coast would be lined with offshore wind farms.

Buck rightly argues that the retirement of nuclear plants makes the situation more difficult. Germany and Japan have decommissioned nuclear power plants. Other states are letting theirs retire at the end of their operating life. Nuclear used to provide 17% of the world’s total electricity generation at its peak in 1996, but now it provides just 10%. A typical nuclear plant provides one gigawatt of power, equivalent to over 3 million solar panels or 400 wind turbines.

Right now, there are just over 400 nuclear reactors in 31 countries, mostly in the United States, France, China, Russia and South Korea. Some new nuclear reactors are getting built, particularly in China. Some new countries are entering, such as Bangladesh, Belarus, Turkey and the United Arab Emirates. But many new nuclear plants are behind schedule.

Difficult to eliminate

Buck makes a number of valuable arguments about the difficulties of completely eliminating emissions from sectors vital to human living standards. Transportation, specifically long-haul aviation and shipping, are two hard nuts to crack. Similarly, “methane emissions from agriculture, such as rice production and particularly from livestock, are tougher to eliminate”. Buck is particularly sharp on so-called “natural” climate solutions:

“Whatever the implementation, there are three main problems with relying on ecosystems to deliver negative emissions. First, there are limitations on land. The most ambitious calculations of afforestation capacity rely on switching to plant-based diets and afforesting land currently grazed by cows – which may not be feasible or just around the world. Second, ecosystem-based carbon removals are finite in terms of how much carbon they can store over time. These carbon sinks, once filled, plateau in terms of what they can continue to remove. Third, ecosystem-based methods are vulnerable to climate change itself. Unchecked climate change could flip forest carbon sinks into carbon emitters by mid-century.?”

Net Zero

Buck also provides a pertinent critique of the “net zero” framing of climate solutions. The net zero concept appears to have originated with an informal network of women – climate activists, lawyers, and policy professionals – who met at a Scottish country estate in 2013 to reformulate workable yet ambitious goals in the wake of the failed Copenhagen climate summit. Net zero thinking made its debut at the 2015 Paris COP summit.

Net zero targets replaced earlier goals, which were often confusing, such as “an 80% reduction of greenhouse gases from 1990 levels by 2050”. Replacing these reduction goals with net zero targets has generally been welcomed as a strengthening of ambition, although not necessarily so.

Buck acknowledges the value of the net zero framing. She argues that “net zero does important work: it shifts attention entirely onto emissions, counting and balancing them”. A progressive version of net zero “could be an instrument of climate justice”.

But net zero is “both tedious and a hot trend”. Net zero “has the effect of being able to instantly transform the exciting, terrifying work of our times into something numb and boring”. Net zero is “the stuff of webinars, white papers, consultant reports”. The concept of net zero offers “ambiguity that can be exploited”. Buck argues:

“The real poverty of net zero, as a language and problem framing, is that it strips out the broader socio-ecological crisis from focus… Net zero shifts the focus away from production… Without a plan for managing the decline of fossil fuels, net-zero talk and nascent carbon removal techniques are likely to be a discursive strategy for companies and countries to continue producing large amounts of fossil fuels. Net zero on its own is the wrong target of climate action. Curbing production and climate justice are both better goals.”

Phaseout

A virtue of Buck’s work is that while the critique is strident, alternatives are offered to improve the situation. Buck uses the framework of “phaseout” rather than “transition” to describe a programme to urgently and deliberately phase down fossil fuels, while ramping up alternatives in a synchronised fashion.

Phasing out fossil fuels has three parts. There are upstream activities, including exploration and extraction – fossil fuel reserves, or stuff underground. Then transport, which includes pipelines, rail lines, ships and liquefied natural gas terminals. Finally, downstream operations include oil refining, distribution (such as gas stations), and power plants. Key demands are:

“Begin with moratoria on exploration and then extraction; incorporate these commitments into a global agreement in which countries can receive acknowledgment for their efforts. Keep pressuring investors not to finance new projects. Phase out subsidies and route them to renewable energy instead. Buy out fossil fuel companies, and institute limits on extraction that will be ramped down each year. Turn these publicly held companies into carbon removal companies, providing jobs for workers formerly employed in fossil fuels. And provide aid to producer countries for offramps around the world.”

Buck demands a more ambitious political project: a worker-centred, publicly owned, democratically planned carbon removal industry. She points to some hopefully signs in the US labour movement, including the Carbon Capture Coalition, Blue-Green Alliance and Solidarity for Climate Action plan. Buck wants to transform the fossil fuel industry and its workforce into a climate mitigation force:

“What we need to do with the fossil fuel industry is put it under public ownership and run it in reverse: transfer the skills and tools to large-scale carbon dioxide storage projects. To be clear, removing carbon from the atmosphere at a climate-significant scale means the creation of a significant new industry. First, it would involve outfitting bioenergy power plants with carbon capture equipment to run biomass carbon removal and storage. It would also involve building facilities of various scales to capture carbon directly from the air (direct air capture), as well as the renewable energy capacity to run these facilities. Creating this industry also means building new CO2 pipelines to transport CO2 from these facilities. Finally, it would involve drilling injection wells deep into underground rock formations and monitoring these wells. Scaling up direct air capture would also bring a surge of demand for equipment and steel—workers in trades like cement, chemicals, equipment manufacturing, and construction.' It is an entire value chain, a new industry from scratch – and it needs to be planned, not left to develop through markets.”

Comments?
We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.