By most statistical measures — levels of union density; number of members covered by collective bargaining agreements; numbers of workplace reps — workers in the railway, including the London Underground, and in the postal service can be considered among the best organised in Britain. They are also able to hit their bosses’ or the government’s income directly by strikes, unlike most public service workers.
Despite ostensibly extensive strikes, neither group has been able to win victories in their 2022-3 campaigns, while gains have been won by some weaker-placed workers. Why?
Part of the reason is that the disputes with Network Rail, the Rail Delivery Group (representing Train Operating Companies, TOCs), and Royal Mail have been not only about pay — and with London Underground Ltd. (LU), not about pay at all. They are disputes in which pay, if a factor at all, has been less central than resisting enormous restructures and changes to terms and conditions, often involving thousands of job cuts. Employers have been committed and determined to drive through change as they have return to routine operation after the Covid lockdowns. They have sometimes posed things in apocalyptic terms, insisting that the future of the industry depends on them being able to make their cuts. Royal Mail bosses have threatened to declare the business insolvent.
Pay disputes often include demands over other conditions, and settlements may involve improvements for workers or productivity gains for bosses, or sometimes both. But in national rail, Royal Mail, and Tube, the disputes have more of an “all or nothing” character.
The problem is that the unions have not launched programmes of action sufficient to win “all” in an “all or nothing” disputes.
RMT, CWU, and Aslef have struck sporadically, usually for one or two days at a time, often with big gaps in between rounds of action. CWU escalated its strikes in Royal Mail in December 2022, but with little follow-up.
Sprint
RMT’s dispute with Network Rail was settled for a below-inflation pay increase and a fudge on terms and conditions that freed the union from having to sign up to Network Rail’s changes, in effect because they were already being implemented. In the Royal Mail dispute, CWU leaders have signed up to a “negotiators’ agreement” that gives Royal Mail much of what it wanted (with below-inflation pay increases) but has suspended the members’ referendum on that deal. The disputes on TOCs and LU continue, but without, so far, any meaningful intensification of action.
Given the stakes, the disputes were only ever likely to be won via escalating strikes. The “marathon, not a sprint” approach which the union leaders consciously proclaimed is never good, even in simpler pay disputes, but least of all good in these higher-stakes battles. The high membership levels, and even high numbers of reps, in rail, mail, and Tube, do not make the workers immune from the long ebb of industrial struggle prior to the 2022/3 wave. Postal workers maintained traditions of militancy and unofficial action on a local level, but had taken no national action since 2009. Prior to 2022, London Underground workers last held network-wide strikes in 2016. Some TOCs had seen strikes in the mid-2010s over the implementation of Driver Only Operation, but there had been no national rail strikes since the 1990s.
Even in higher-density industries, over that long ebb union membership often came to be seen as something akin to taking out an insurance policy. It was sometimes consciously promoted by unions as such. RMT used the “insurance for your job” analogy in promotional materials. A workforce where large numbers of workers are union members, but typically see the union as something largely external to which a fee is paid in exchange for the service of “protection”, is not a truly “well organised” workforce.
To change that, socialists active in unions need to win a different approach to industrial action, and a different approach to the day-to-day functioning of the union in the workplace.