North East mayor: almost half of CLPs refuse to nominate

Of the 22 Constituency Labour Parties (CLPs) in the catchment for the new “North-East mayor” to be elected in May 2024, eight have voted to make no nomination for Labour candidate for mayor.

Hexham, Wansbeck, Blyth Valley, Blaydon, Newcastle East, Newcastle Central, Easington, and City of Durham have voted that way to protest against the 2 June decision by a panel of Labour’s National Executive to exclude Jamie Driscoll, current Labour North of Tyne mayor, from the longlist.

Three CLPs did not meet to consider nominations, and two nominated all the candidates longlisted. Only nine nominated the Labour leadership favourite, Kim McGuinness, despite heavy bureaucratic pressure in meetings (some declared nominations made without taking a vote of those present, just asking for a proposer and seconder; one CLP chair threatened members with expulsion for even mentioning Driscoll’s name). Gateshead council Labour group also refused to make a nomination.

This response shows that it is possible to organise resistance in CLPs even after all the attrition under Starmer (and, in some CLPs, indeed, that those unjustly expelled in recent years for left-wing views can still help, if they have made a point of continuing with what Labour activity is open to them).

Unite, the FBU, and TSSA have protested against the exclusion, as have some Labour mayors such as Andy Burnham. Unison, GMB, and Community have nominated McGuinness. We don’t know about the CWU or Aslef or Usdaw.

Driscoll’s exclusion is unjustified in the most literal sense: the NEC panel has published no reason. Unofficially, Starmer supporters suggest he has been excluded for sharing a platform with the film director Ken Loach.

But that was for a discussion of Loach’s films, which are widely appreciated and some of which are set in the north-east.

Loach was expelled from Labour in 2021 for association with “Labour Against the Witch-hunt”, a small group set up around expulsions on grounds of antisemitism, by people who had mostly sat on their hands while Labour purged hundreds or thousands of members in 2015-6 just for left-wing associations. That doesn’t make Driscoll guilty by association. There is no evidence against him of antisemitism.

Driscoll is broadly speaking on the Labour left. He has not much radical record, except on anti-fascism — he was a prosperous businessman before becoming a Labour councillor in 2018 — and Labour activists in the north-east tell us he might well have lost the selection to McGuinness anyway; but the ultra-Blairites in Starmer’s circle went for the tightest control.

Probably the Labour hierarchy will now push through the mayoral selection as fast as they can, then fob off all complaints with calls to unite behind McGuinness once selected.

It looks like some of Driscoll’s supporters may want him to run as an independent (almost certainly not affiliated to any such group as TUSC, Northern Independence Party, Socialist Labour Party, etc., and probably on a “proven effective local leader” rather than specially left-wing basis).

In the North of Tyne mayor election of 2019 Driscoll got 33.9%, the Tories 24.9%, a Chamber of Commerce independent 17.2%, and Driscoll won on transfers. The North East mayor election of May 2024 will be first past the post. The change in area covered is favourable to Labour, and general opinion poll trends are too, but the electoral calculus for 2024 remains unclear.

Whatever about that, a Driscoll candidacy looks more likely to disperse the left — to be a staging-post for fed-up Labour members on the way out of politics — than to rally it (as Ken Livingstone’s successful run for London mayor in 2000 on an anti-PPP platform arguably did, for all its faults).

Large progress in reversing Starmer’s “Thermidorian reaction” is unlikely as long as the general election is ahead, Starmer looks like winning it, and the unions remain unwilling to use their clout within Labour’s structures. But small bits of progress and re-rallying of the left now can be very important for the kickback sure to come as a Starmer government proves dismal.


On 15 June LabourList reported:

Trade union leaders have written a joint letter to Labour’s leader and governing body over the exclusion of Jamie Driscoll from a mayoral shortlist, calling it a “monumental own goal”.

The letter, seen by LabourList, was signed by the general secretaries of the RMT, ASLEF, CWU, FBU and BFAWU, as well as the leaders of UCU and POA in a personal capacity. [Not Unite? We don't know]

“Working people need a strong voice like Jamie. We are calling for common sense to prevail and for Jamie to be given the opportunity to stand in the selection to be Labour candidate for North East mayor,” it reads.

“We are astonished and dismayed that Jamie Driscoll is being prevented from being considered as Labour’s candidate for the North East mayoralty. To exclude a politician of Jamie’s calibre and commitment represents a monumental own goal. Jamie has already proved to be an outstanding mayor for the North of Tyne.”

Comments?
We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.