No to detention ships and camps

The Conservatives’ torrent of anti-migrant measures continues, with the Illegal Migration Bill (IMB) progressing through Parliament.

The IMB virtually abolishes the right to claim asylum, and other protections, for anyone arriving via small boats and other irregular routes.

There are few safe, regularised options, so most refugees will be expelled, imprisoned, or permanently trapped on the margins of society, in destitution and at risk of deportation.

Even expanded safe routes and humanitarian visas could never cover all the desperate situations in which people are forced to flee their homes and seek sanctuary. The right to escape danger by any means necessary, and claim asylum on arrival, is an essential part of any refugee system.

Home Secretary Suella Braverman has also announced a ban preventing most international students from bringing their families with them. Starmer’s Labour leadership refuses to oppose it.

And the Home Office has diverted more than £3m from aid to fund Turkish border forces. These repel migrants with extreme violence, including firing live rounds at adults and children.

Sunak’s quiet dropping of the existing two-tier policy which means asylum seekers arriving irregularly have to wait until after regular arrivals to have their claims considered will help many who are still awaiting decisions on their claims. But the reprieve is limited — if and when the IMB passes, all who have arrived or will arrive after 6 March 2023 will be subject to its new regime.

Housing for asylum seekers (who are banned from supporting themselves through work or social security while awaiting processing) continues to worsen.

Forty were left on the street after the Home Office tried to pack them four to a room in a cramped London hotel — it took two days of protests by the refugees and supporters to force a U-turn. 8,000 Afghans who came to the UK fleeing the Taliban face eviction onto the streets.

At asylum accommodation run by outsourcing giant Serco, workers whistle-blew on bullying and abuse. They accused senior managers of harassment, humiliation, intimidation, racism, withholding of food and mismanagement of medical care. The Home Office has backed its corporate contractor.

Barges

Plans are progressing to cram refugees into prison-barge-style ships with limited access to the outside world. And the government is plotting for slum landlords by exempting them from basic standards when housing asylum seekers, including gas and electrical safety and minimum room sizes.

Despite some incremental legal wins and organising and action by campaigners including refugees, political opposition to the government’s agenda remains dangerously muted. Labour leaders persist in their shameful strategy of pandering to xenophobia, breaching both party policy and Starmer’s pledges. Most trade union leaders fail to follow up positive words with significant action. And extra-parliamentary opposition is punching far below its weight.

Resistance

Direct resistance to raids and deportations is vital and brave work. Legal work has achieved limited but life-saving reprieves. Lobbying for amendments can blunt this or that aspect of Tory legislation (though it can risk diverting or moderating overall opposition). But these are rearguard actions. We cannot turn the tide without a large-scale, mass-participation political offensive.

Despite the toxic parliamentary and press atmosphere and far-right mobilisation, there is also significant public sympathy for refugees and revulsion at Conservative policies. Those people could be a major force, and could win round others too. Yet there has been little opportunity for them to participate in large-scale demonstrations of their opposition, or to be invited into sustained activist organising for a positive alternative. Mass protest is not a complete answer, but nor is it dispensable.

The reiteration of threats by civil service workers in PCS to strike against the Rwanda deportation plan is a glimmer of light. They deserve the encouragement and solidarity of the whole labour movement. Their activity could also be a launchpad for a wider political mobilisation.

Campaigners have rightly criticised the double standards and implied racism of creating bespoke schemes for Ukrainians and Hongkongers, while refusing one to, for example, Sudanese people fleeing the civil war. Delayed asylum and family reunion decisions continue to put Sudan refugees in danger, or force them onto dangerous criminalised routes. (The flawed schemes for Ukraine and Hong Kong should not be prettified, either)

While people in danger need specific evacuation operations and escape routes, we should not demand a multiplication of crisis-by-crisis resettlement schemes. That would rely too much on the government’s calculations each time. We must fight instead for a consistent, permanent policy of free passage and welcome. An end to criminalisation, detention, and deportation. Rights for asylum seekers and all migrants, from their day of arrival: to permanent residency; to decent housing within communities; to work; to access equal social security and public services; and to appropriate support for survivors of war, persecution, torture and abuse.

Common interests

As workers, we combat division by highlighting our common interests regardless of birthplace. Rather than competing against one another for scraps, we organise to battle together, for a massive redistribution of wealth and power from the rich to the whole working class.

Our goal is a world where we are all free to move and stay across the planet with liberty, equality and a good life wherever we are. At present free movement is a privilege of the rich and powerful. Socialists fight to make that privilege into a universal right.

Comments?
We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.