Revising James Connolly

Austen Morgan, James Connolly

Sean Matgamna reviews ‘James Connolly: a political biography’ by Austen Morgan (Manchester University Press)

This is commonly agreed to be the age of revisionism in Irish historiography. Or is it the first age of Irish historiography worth speaking about as history?

Austen Morgan's book is a coolly revisionist, deliberately deflating assessment of James Connolly, the socialist and labour activist who was the military leader of the 1916 Rising in Dublin, after which the British Army shot him.

The major previous biography of Connolly was by the Stalinist author Desmond Greaves, who died last year. According to his paper, the Irish Democrat, Greaves denounced Morgan almost with his last breath as typical of the new breed of debunkers and historical myth-smashers.

Until perhaps 25 or 30 years ago, heroic tales and myths did service for Irish history. Orange myths and Green myths did ghostly battle with each other in the schoolroom, above an Ireland slumbering (with occasional kicks and twitches) through the quiet decades before Northern Ireland erupted in 1968-9.

When the ancient Green and Orange battle was resumed in real life, that stirred many people to debunk, discredit and bury the myths, and to set about establishing accurate history. The drive to revise received history was in fact already well underway, but events after 1969 boosted it enormously. The alarmed southern Irish bourgeoisie, having been in power for half a century, felt an increasingly urgent need to cut away its own revolutionary past.

That is hardly surprising. Far more surprising is that they left it so late; surprising too is what the tepid and small-minded rulers of the right-wing and intensely Catholic 26 County state had been saying about themselves and their history.

Until well into the "60s, at least, the southern Irish schools taught a version of Irish history more or less identical to what the Provisional IRA today teaches its recruits. They told the terrible story of the ancient subjugation of the Irish, of the repeated massacres and land-confiscations. They taught us how Ireland’s Catholics were outlawed and persecuted in the 18th century under the ‘Penal Laws’, a system of helotry very like South Africa’s apartheid.

They taught history as the struggle of oppressors and oppressed, whose heroes were the revolutionaries. They gloried in the various risings — often exaggerating their scope and importance, seizing on anything that could be construed as evidence of national virility and proof that the Irish never accepted their corporation into the ‘English system’.

Where British school children learned the dates of kings, we learned the dates of risings — 1641, 1689-90, 1798, 1803, 1848, 1867, 1916... Our history was our struggle for liberation; our heroes were not conquerors but rebels and freedom fighters whose glory lay in plotting or leading a rising, and then bearing their martyrdom bravely, defying their enemy with a ‘speech from the dock’. They were good speeches, too, some of them, which we were taught to recite.

Of course there was 2 heavy overlap here with religious ideas of martyrs bearing witness for the faith. Protestants had a parallel tradition, but we didn’t hear about that, and for us the national cause and Catholicism were entwined like tendrils of ivy on an ancient wall.

‘The ideas and symbols were interchangeable. They cast a glow on each other. The cause of Ireland was the cause of the Catholic Church; the cause of the Catholic Church 'was the cause of Ireland. To this we sing ‘Faith of our Fathers' at All-Ireland Hurling Finals, as they sing ‘You'll never walk alone’ at Wembley: "Faith of our fathers living still, in spite of dungeon, fire and sword".

The great modern Irish hero was Padraig Pearse, the President of the Republic proclaimed in 1916, shot by the British after he surrendered — a man with a highly visible Messiah complex, who in his poems and plays more or less openly aspired to play the role of Christ-like redeemer to the suffering Irish nation.

Pearse wove together disparate strands of Catholicism, 19th century Fenian nationalism, 18th century Republicanism, and the intense and sometimes mystical nationalism that swept over Europe in the early part of this century, into the ideology of the Irish Catholic bourgeoisie’s political revolution, through which it won independence from Britain in 1922. (The social revolution, the dismantling of the landlord system in favour of peasant proprietorship, had been made from above by British Tory and Liberal governments at the turn of the century.)

How come the Southern state was teaching its children the same history that the Provisional IRA now teaches? Both the dominant Southern Irish parties, Fianna Fail and Fine Gael, and the Provisionals, have common roots: they are splinters from one party, the second Sinn Fein of 1917-1922.

Of course, the Southern state had a shortish way with individuals who got the wrong message, who decided that it was not just a matter of ancient heroes from the dim and misty years and that they themselves should carry on the tradition of rebellion that they had been taught to revere. For them the state had the jail, the firing squad, and the concentration camp, in which young men were interned without trial in several periods up to 1957-9.

Yet people did take that tradition of rebellion seriously, and not only Irish people. Irish Catholic missionaries took the message of Ireland’s struggles with them all over the world. There are many examples of the influence of Irish nationalism in Africa; Robert Mugabe, the president of Zimbabwe, for example, came under the influence of Irish missionaries, and one of the first things he did after he won power in 1980 was to go over to Ireland on a sort of political pilgrimage.

In Ireland, the logic of the version of history we were taught could lead not only to the IRA but further. If you generalised that picture of history to the world around you in the '50s and "60s — with the Algerians fighting the French, the Greek Cypriots fighting the British, Africans demanding their freedom and organising ‘Mau Mau’ in Kenya — then you would arrive at general anti-colonialist and anti-imperialist politics.

And if you went from the Irish countryside or small town to industrial England, and assumed your place in the lower orders of the proletariat, then the step from concern for national freedom to concern for working-class freedom, towards socialism or communism, was a very short one. Many made the transition; that many more didn’t is probably to be accounted for by the power of the Catholic strand in the mixture.

No wonder the Southern state began to change its official history. Now a posse of historians is beavering away. They are trying to replace the heroic myths with dry-as-dust facts and statistics, and to banish, like mist from the morning, all vestiges of the revolutionary outlook on life.

James Connolly has a strange place in all this: a national hero of Catholic Ireland who was also a Marxist! But he was a man full of contradictions: the Marxist who lost his life in a foredoomed nationalist rising, the militant socialist who made his peace at the end with the then very reactionary Catholic Church.

In the pantheon of the 26 County state Connolly was accorded an important place, but one definitely subordinate to Pearse. The Marxist and revolutionary socialist (communist, in Inter parlance) was reduced to ‘the labour leader’, Only the left, including, naturally, the Republican left, tried to keep a notion of what Connolly really was.

The bourgeoisie and the Church said that Connolly had ceased to be a socialist. It was as late as 1941 that the first collection of his writings was produced — by the Communist Party, concerned to use Connolly’s writings during World War 1 to justify their stand (formally anti-imperialist, actually favourable to Nazi Germany) between the Stalin-Hitler pact in 1939 and Hitler's invasion of the Soviet Union in June 1941.

The CP’s Connolly was, of course, truer to the real person than the bloodless figure lined up with the other heroes in the Irish bourgeoisie’s shrines.

As the drift, and then stampede, away from idealistic Pearse-centred history got under way, the balance shifted in favour of Connolly. But this was a new Connolly again — Connolly the practical-minded no-nonsense man. Connolly was indeed a ‘man for all seasons’. It depends on which bit of him you caught sight of.

For Austen Morgan, Connolly was a socialist who abandoned socialism to go over to nationalism after World War 1 broke out. Morgan rejects the idea — even for 1916 — that there could be a socialist struggle by way of the national struggle, within it and coming out of it. He can find no reason to believe that Connolly said what the trade union leader O'Brien said Connolly said before going out on Easter Monday: “The odds against us are a thousand to one, but in the event of victory hold on to your rifles, as those with whom we are fighting may stop before our goal is reached".

Whether Connolly said it or not, the words reflect the spirit of Marx’s advice to his comrades in 1850; that socialists and bourgeois revolutionaries should strike together in national-democratic revolutions, but march separately. It seems to me impossible to doubt that Connolly acted in that spirit.

The same idea was to be repeated in one of the key documents of revolutionary socialism in the 20th century — the Communist International's 1920 Theses on the National and Colonial Question.

To be sure, the great and immensely tragic weakness of Connolly was that he did not build a revolutionary movement able to lead and shape the nationalist upsurge that followed 1916, Had the post-1916 Irish national movement been shaped by Connolly's class politics, then it might very well have appealed to the Protestant workers of Northern Ireland on a working-class basis, across the sectarian-communal divide.

Connolly did have many of the faults of his generation of Marxian socialists, and some, like his Catholicism, which were peculiar to himself. But he was right to base himself on the just struggle of the great majority of the Irish people against their national oppression. In doing so he made a step forward from the political common stock of his generation of Marxists, who generally had little interest in the revolts of oppressed nations.

That Connolly was, so to speak, politically gobbled up by the bourgeois nationalists after his death and made into one of their plaster-of-Paris saints, proves only that he lost, not that he was wrong to make the attempt.

The early Communist International gave much thought to the problem of dealing with nationalist rebellions, and even its ideas, based on far wider experience and discussion than Connolly ever had access to, could not prevent the Chinese Communist Party making errors similar to Connolly's, and of catastrophic proportions, in the 1920s.

There is an implicit assumption in Austen Morgan’s criticism of Connolly that he should have chosen to struggle for the unity of the Irish working class by fighting for socialism within the old United Kingdom and having no truck with Irish separatism. But that would have meant Connolly turning his back on the democratic demands fought for by the big majority of the Irish people for many, many decades (at least), and trying to get the labour movement to do the same. No Irish labour movement could have been built with such politics — only (in most of Ireland) sterile Unionist sects. On that road there was no possible solution to the Unionist/Nationalist division — only the self-isolation of the socialists and the strengthening of the bourgeois and petty bourgeois nationalists.

Connolly's understanding of the character and depth of the Catholic/Protestant division in Ireland was inadequate. On the other hand, no-one has ever written with more biting class hatred of Catholic-Nationalist bigotry than did Connolly in his writings against the Ancient Order of Hibernians and the old Home Rule party.

Austen Morgan's book reads to me too ‘academic’ and a bit too summary, as if it has been cut down too brutally from a much longer draft.

It is a sustained assault on the image of Connolly held today by the revolutionary left; in fact, though from a different view point, Morgan paints a picture of Connolly rather like that of our schools in De Valera’s Ireland. For Morgan too, Connolly ceased to be a socialist when he became the rebel hero our teachers lauded and Morgan rather regrets.

Austen Morgan is a socialist, not one of the bourgeois revisionists of Irish history. But his enterprise must be understood in relation to theirs.

They want to destroy the heroic myths of Irish history as a struggle of the oppressed against the oppressor. In many ways the project resembles the evolution of a section of the Russian intelligentsia in the 1890s away from the heroic Narodnik tradition of struggle against Tsarism. They became ‘hard-headed’ — and reconciled to capitalism.

For a while, strangely, a big section of the bourgeois-oriented intelligentsia used Marxism as a cutting edge against the Narodnik revolutionary tradition. The Russian Marxists had to fight both Narodnism and the anti-revolutionary negation of Narodnism by the ‘Legal Marxists’.

What will replace the now discredited idealist-nationalist version of Irish history? Will the tremendously positive and wise core of that history — the necessity and justice of the struggle of the oppressed against the oppressor — be lost, cut away by the academic scalpels? Or will it be incorporated into an adequate and comprehensive Marxist history of Ireland, as the heroic tradition of Narodnism was absorbed into Russian Marxism?

The critical work of the revisionists can help with the creation of a new, revolutionary-oriented but proletarian, account of Irish history. It depends on what the Marxists do with their work.

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.