Lousy night in Georgia

Second International delegation visits Menshevik Georgia

Eric Lee predictably and wrongly seizes on my recent review on the Russian civil war to rehash fairy tales about Georgia’s Menshevik government (Solidarity 642, 27 July 2022). Lee’s apologetics ignore the reality of the period – include materials from his own book, The Experiment (2017). Rather than put the Russian civil war in its international context, he prefers the fantasy oasis of social democracy in one country.

In October 1917, the Bolsheviks led the working class to make a socialist revolution in Russia. They led a revolutionary workers’ government. The Bolsheviks faced White military threats from the moment they took power and intervention from numerous imperialist powers.

The Bolsheviks were never “at peace” with the German empire. The German government imposed bitter, imperialist terms on the Bolsheviks in early 1918, under the duress of their overwhelming military superiority. The Bolsheviks were forced to sign the treaty and concede territory to fend off their complete obliteration by the German army and to keep their pledge to stop the war. The Georgian Mensheviks, led by Noe Zhordania, established a breakaway bourgeois republic.

The Georgian Mensheviks were not “neutral” between the domestic forces of the Russian civil war. As Trotsky explained in his book,Between Red and White, on 25 September 1918, an official conference was held, consisting of the representatives of the Georgian republic, the Kuban government and the Volunteer Army. The Georgian representatives said they were carrying on a relentless struggle against Bolshevism, crushing it with all the means at its disposal. The proceedings were published by the Georgian government, in a blue book, Documents and Materials on the Foreign Policy of Trans-Caucasia and Georgia (1919).

Nor were the Georgian Mensheviks indifferent to foreign intervention. Lee’s own book describes how Georgia under the Mensheviks became a German protectorate:

“Zhordania later wrote that when the German commanding general requested that Georgia support the Central Powers (Germany, Austria and Turkey) in the world war, he replied: ‘I have never considered the international position of Georgia as that of an absolutely neutral state, as the contrary is being proved by evident facts.’ Zhordania described Georgia’s policy as being one of ‘limited neutrality’. Georgia’s neutrality, he wrote, was limited ‘by the very fact of the presence of General Von Kress and his soldiers on our territory during the world war’.”

After Germany was defeated in the world war, the British army swiftly moved into Georgia. Lee stated in his book: “In early December 1918 the first British troops arrived... Early in the new year, the Georgian government held a welcoming banquet for the British military mission, while at the very same time the war minister also gave General Kress a farewell dinner.” Whatever the disputes, Georgia remained under British protection and supported Denikin and Wrangel’s White armies. On 14 January 1920, Zhordania made the Georgian Mensheviks’ position clear: “You know that Soviet Russia has proposed a military alliance with us. We have point blank declined. Our answer must be known to you... I must say here most emphatically: that I prefer the imperialists of the West to the fanatics of the East.”

In my original review (Solidarity 641, 13 July 2022), I described Antony Beevor’s book as pretty dismal. But at least Beevor recognises some of the interconnections between domestic White forces and big power intervention. The Georgian Mensheviks were hostile to the Bolsheviks and on the wrong side of the conflict, domestically and internationally. No adequate Marxist assessment can ignore that.

Paul Vernadsky, London

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.