Standing Together Jewish-Arab protest in Israel
On 1 February 2022 Amnesty International published a report saying that the Israeli state’s “oppression and domination” of Palestinians “amounts to apartheid”.
Amnesty’s practical conclusion is only to seek to nudge the Israeli government to do better, with a petition calling on the Israeli government to stop house demolitions (which are indeed grievous).
The headline of the report aliments the already-widespread view of Israel as a unique pariah state, as South Africa was before 1994. In the small print Amnesty clarifies that it “does not seek to argue that... oppression and domination as perpetrated in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT) is... analogous to the system... perpetrated in South Africa between 1948 and 1994”. It is indeed not analogous to actual historical apartheid. It is colonial occupation of the West Bank - brutal in the style of a colonial occupation - and national-minority disadvantage of Palestinian citizens of Israel. The description as “apartheid” relies on using that term as a general word for all severe oppression.
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been and is fundamentally a national conflict - one in which the Palestinians have been cruelly and repeatedly defeated, and often been the main victims of conflicts primarily between neighbouring Arab states (not the Palestinians themselves) and Israel. The answer is the right of self-determination for both nations - for both the Israeli Jews, who already have it, and the Palestinians, who lack it. Amnesty says, ambiguously, that it “recognises that both the Jewish and the Palestinian people claim the right to self-determination”, without saying whether it recognises that right for them. Oddly, it does not even call for Israel to withdraw from the West Bank and cede the Palestinians their right to a state of their own, and at one point says that it recognises there can be good reason for abrogating some liberties under occupation.
The report is skewed by sloppiness in detail, but also by interpreting all the issues as of racial rather than national oppression. The two are different, though one can spill over to another.
The report is written as if Israeli misdeeds have all been gratuitous acts of unforced prejudice, without reference to most of the early citizens of Israel being refugees and facing decades of threats from larger neighbouring states to wipe out their “liferaft state”. That slant is reconciled with a perspective of nudging Israel, by petitions and the like, to ease oppression “one pillar at a time”, through an idea that the nudging will finally dissolve Israel via a mass “return” by Palestinians across the world to where their grandparents or great-grandparents lived.
Socialist Worker claims with some justice that “the argument [the report] makes point[s] to nothing else” than “dismantling the Israeli state” and regrets that Amnesty “doesn’t say [it] openly”.
“Dismantling” a state whose people are determined to defend their political unit (even if they dislike its current regime) cannot be done one nudge at a time. It can be done only by suppressing, breaking up, conquering. Both the perspective of nudging and that of conquering are dead ends.
Better solidarity with democratic movements inside Israel like Standing Together, and with campaigns in the West Bank against Israeli occupation, to win “two nations, two states”.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us