Before responding at any length, best wait until Mark Fischer gets further in his promised series of articles. By then WW readers should have an idea of his substantive arguments, and, with luck, sight of the "substantial piece" by Sean Matgamna which he is "centrally" responding to, Sean's "Critical Notes" , rather than just quotations filleted so as to "prove" that the AWL misrepresents CPGB/WW politics.
One point, however, cries out for immediate comment: Stalinism.
In WW 403 (11/10/01) Mark himself proudly introduced a reprint of an article published in 1982 on the April 1978 Stalinist coup in Afghanistan. Mark admitted some "flaws, reflecting the illusions and theoretical errors characteristic of the extreme left wing of 'official communism'", in the article, but did not find it necessary to specify those "flaws" further, and on the whole praised the article as excellent proof that the Stalinist PDPA had led "a genuine democratic revolution". The article itself compared the April 1978 coup at length and without disfavour to October 1917 in Russia.
Sean was "astounded... that you still hold to the line on Afghanistan while you held when you were Stalinists". Mark responds: "We were not 'Stalinists' in 1981, when we begun publishing... our previous stance [before the early 1990s, when the CPGB/WW broke from the idea of the Stalinist USSR having been any sort of workers' state] had far more of 'Trotskyism' about it than 'Stalinism'..."
I turn to From October to August, a book published by the CPGB in 1992. "For all his faults, his mistakes, his championing of bureaucratic socialism, nothing should be allowed to detract from the positive developments in the Soviet Union during the years when Joseph Vissarionovich Stalin led the USSR...
"The conditions were established for a string of socialist states in Eastern Europe and the emergence of the Soviet Union as the second most powerful country on earth. To say the least, this achievement owed not a little to Stalin...
"Against Gorbachev we obviously defend the Stalin of the five year plans, the Stalin of collectivisation, the Stalin of industrialisation, the Stalin of World War II and the Stalin of the spread of socialism into Eastern Europe. We proudly and unhesitatingly defend the forward march of socialism over which Stalin presided..."
"The Soviet Republic's war against Poland [in 1920]... was no different in essence from its war against Nazi Germany, except that the war against Poland failed and that against Nazi Germany succeeded. They were both revolutionary wars which from being defensive became offensive. Being an international continuation of the Soviet state's policy by violent means, the victories of the Red Army of 1944 and 1945 created extremely favourable conditions for the creation of socialist states in Eastern Europe. This is as clear an example as one could want of the class struggle conducted on an international scale by the Soviet Union".
The book also contained criticism of "bureaucratic socialism" and even of the great Joseph Vissarionovich himself. In 1955, say, that criticism would have got you expelled from the (real) CPGB as "Trotskyites". By 1992 it was commonplace.
You didn't see any "Trotskyism" in your views then! "Because of their worship of anti-bureaucratic spontaneity [i.e. their support for elemental working-class resistance to Stalinism] the Trotskyites have always in practice been calling for counter-revolution in the socialist countries".
That the SWP, in particular, espoused "the most reactionary conclusions" was "clear from its response to the August [1991] counter-revolution [in the USSR]: 'Communism has collapsed' it headlined, and this supposed 'fact' should 'have every socialist rejoicing'. The SWP is simply the most explicit anti-communist group on the revolutionary left".
"There can be no playing 'Neither Washington nor Moscow' games when it comes to counter-revolution", you insisted. "What the SWP indulges in is typical of most of the left in Britain - workerism and a worship of abstract democracy".
You also denounced the SWP for another of its more creditable activities, its money-raising for an attempted independent socialist-oriented trade union movement in the USSR in 1990. "Communists should guard the unity of the trade union movement in the USSR".
You took pride in your slogan of "unconditional defence of the socialist countries" - against the working class if necessary. "Tony Chater, the editor of the Morning Star - whom the ignorant bourgeois media dubs a 'tankie' - says tanks don't solve anything. Well, that's not true. Under certain circumstances tanks do solve things. Ask Stalin. He solved the problem of German invasion with tanks".
Retrospectively you endorsed the Russian invasions of Hungary (1956) and Czechoslovakia (1968). "The only way to save the situation for socialism in Hungary was... a call by the new government, led by Kadar, for Soviet intervention". "What was posed in 1968 was defending existing bureaucratic socialism or the Dubcek capitalist road. For genuine communists the interests of the world revolution demanded the former and we must have the courage to say that faced with such a choice Czech and Slovak national rights had to take second place".
You "supported the banning of Solidarnosc in 1981 because of the imminent danger of counter-revolution". You "support[ed] the presence of Soviet forces in Afghanistan". You semi-supported the attempted conservative coup in the USSR in August 1991. "The road to counter-revolution in the USSR will not after all be paved with Gorbachevite good intentions. The State Emergency Committee has seen to that. For communists, for all genuine partisans of the working class, anything that, even momentarily, stays the hand of counter-revolution is good!"
You thought that by 1991 the power of bureaucratic tanks to "solve things" for socialism was reaching its limits. "You can only keep the masses passive with tanks if, after you have sent them [tanks, not the masses] onto the streets, you give the population steadily increasing living standards. Yes, that might have been a crude bureaucratic way to handle problems, but as long as bureaucratic socialism was only a relative fetter, it could do it".
Nevertheless, your chief pride was that even at the last, "genuine Leninists never wavered in our pro-Soviet stance". Right up to the end, you defended the USSR as "the world revolutionary centre".
In previous discussions with the AWL, you conceded frankly that you used to be "left Stalinists". There is no shame in coming to think that one started off at the wrong place in politics, and that one has learned many things since - so long as one's previous errors are unsparingly recognised and analysed. But how can you learn the lessons of your break from Stalinism if you deny that it ever had to take place?
Martin Thomas
Help support our work!
We have no big money backers. We rely on sales and donations to keep us going.
If you appreciate the socialist analysis and debate on this website please consider donating to support our work.
Or take out a subscription to our weekly paper, Solidarity.