Scotland

Scottish left pulled into SNP vortex

The working class voted “yes”. The Labour Party is finished. And we need a new mass socialist party.

To one degree or another, and in one form or another, these have been the three main responses of the pro-independence left to the result of the 18 September referendum.

The first element has some degree of truth to it. Three of the four regions which had a “yes” majority (even if not a very large one) are traditional Labour strongholds. The fourth (Dundee) used to be a Labour stronghold, until New Labour decided the sitting Labour MP John McAllion was a liability.

Any socialist welcoming “the working-class 'yes’ vote” in the Scottish independence referendum is welcoming the divisive poison of nationalism penetrating into working-class politics. To try to build on that basis — as the pro-independence left is now attempting — amounts to adding another dose of the same poison.

Around the world: 

The AWL, Labour and the Left: 

Publications: 

Plans for consistent democracy

Author: 

Matt Cooper

Solidarity 337 was right to pose a plan of consistent democracy in response to the Scottish referendum.

This is far better than the wrong-headedness of much of the left’s “Cuba of the north” fantasies about Scottish independence. It is also the right riposte to the inconsistent and undemocratic response of the mainstream Westminster parties. Solidarity was, however, wrong in both its overall approach to the democratic demands raised and the detailed content.

Devolution, a good approximate answer to the desire of Scottish people to have more say over their own affairs, is a compromise, but a compromise with the least problems.

Issues and Campaigns: 

Around the world: 

Publications: 

After Scottish shock, reshape Britain!

Author: 

Editorial

Scotland is not settled. The whole British political system has been unsettled.

The majority on 18 September against separation — 55 to 45 per cent — was bigger than expected, and Solidarity is glad the vote went that way. We said “reduce borders, not raise them”.

But the Scottish National Party reports an influx of 10,000 new members. There is a storm on Twitter with the #45 hashtag, with which the 18 September percentage for separation spookily link their cause to the feudal-reactionary revolt of 1745, which started in Scotland.

Britain should become a democratic, federal republic.

Issues and Campaigns: 

Around the world: 

Publications: 

Imagine...

Author: 

Dale Street

Imagine you’re attending a union meeting in your workplace. Your workplace rep is reporting back from a meeting with management:

“Here’s the offer management has put on the table. There’s 6,300 members covered by the national collective bargaining agreement. Management is proposing to give the 500 of us here our own separate bargaining unit.

I think it’s a great offer. The last time we had a ballot on a pay deal, we got outvoted by the other 5,800 members down south. Now, if we get our own bargaining unit, we’ll always get the pay deal we want.

A parable about the Scottish referendum.

Around the world: 

After the referendum

Author: 

Dale Street

The Scottish referendum debate drew in thousands of people who had not been previously involved in political argument and activity. Public meetings attracted capacity crowds. Political discussion became a mass activity.

When passions run high, as they did in the referendum debate, there will inevitably be excesses. Activists on both sides were equally guilty of such excesses. And, in the end, they were peripheral to the big political debate.

The Scottish referendum campaign mobilised thousands, but the nationalist project was divisive.

Publications: 

Around the world: 

Survey

The political vacuum in Albania (Colin Foster)
Levers for the lovers of power (Joan Trevor)
Blair wins a place in the Sun (Jim Denham)
Glasgow councillors abandon election pledges (Stan Crooke)
Tony Blair and the union laws. (Tom Rigby)
Letter from prison (Dita Sari)
Anti-abortion campaign, a winning scheme? (Helen Rate)
Should holocaust denial be a crime?
Iranian oil workers dare to fight
Obituary: Coin Coyle
The left and the election

A round-up of news from WL39

The AWL, Labour and the Left: 

Culture and Reviews: 

Around the world: 

Publications: 

Trade Unions: 

Issues and Campaigns: 

Pages