Solidarity newspaper

WL magazine


 

Search Workers' Liberty sites using Scroogle


User login

Change user status...

Join the debate!

We welcome debate and encourage free discussion. Log in with a user name, and you can add comments to the debates on this site. We operate no political censorship, but we reserve the usual editorial right to delete or cut comments which are racist or sexist; advertising; abusive; excessive in volume; or otherwise inappropriate.


Navigation

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate


Socialism and Democracy: AWL Debate with Michael Foot

Democracy

Was advocating extra-parliamentary direct action to bring down the elected Thatcher government anti-democratic? Are 'by democratic means' and 'by parliamentary means' identical concepts?

Former Labour leader Michael Foot, who we debated in this pamphlet in 1982, and on the same issues at a public meeting in 1993, has just died. While sending sympathy and condolences to his family, friends and comrades, we draw the attention of socialists and labour movement activists to this debate as part of the discussion on Foot's political legacy.

Socialism and Democracy: Workers' Liberty special issue (no.17), January 1994
------
Download the pamphlet as a PDF:

  • Debate from 1982 between Michael Foot, then Labour Party leader, and John O'Mahony (Sean Matgamna), with a 1994 introduction

  • Appendices, including texts on socialism and democracy by James P Cannon, Max Shachtman, V I Lenin, and Hal Draper.

------
Read it online:
Introduction: Democracy, direct action, and the class struggle
Michael Foot: My kind of democracy (part 1)
Michael Foot: My kind of democracy (part 2)
John O'Mahony: Introduction
Chapter 1: Is Direct Action Against Thatcher Undemocratic?
Chapter 2: The Appeal to History
Chapter 3: The Scarecrow of Stalinism
Chapter 4: Superstition or Struggle?
Appendix 1. Labour Party: the sham of "one member, one vote" - John Bloxam and John O'Mahony
Appendix 2. PR, democracy, and socialism - John O'Mahony
Appendix 3. Marxism and democracy - James P Cannon
Appendix 4. The movement of the majority - James P Cannon
Appendix 5. 1917 was a democratic revolution - Max Shachtman
Appendix 6. Lenin on Democracy and Dictatorship
Appendix 7. Democracy in the Russian Revolution - Leon Trotsky (1918)
Appendix 8. An Eyewitness Account of the Russian Revolution - Hal Draper

Appendix 7 and appendix 8, included here, were not in the printed version of January 1994.


Workers' Liberty 3/11: 1917 - revolution for freedom and equality

Marxism and Stalinism

The Russian Revolution, the Stalinist counter-revolution, and the working class (Analyses from Labor Action and The New International, 1942 to 1957)
Download pdfs (without pictures): pages 1 to 8; pages 9 to 16.


Was the 1916 Rising a "Putsch"? Lenin, Radek, Trotsky.

Vladimir Lenin
Author: 
Sean Matgamnna

[This is part of a polemic about the Stalinist PDP led army coup in Afghanistan, in April 1978, with "J-J" (Jack Conrad/John Bridge/John Chamberlain) of the Weekly Worker Group "CPGB").


Introduction

Marxism and Stalinism

It is 20 years since the destruction of the Berlin Wall by the people of then divided Germany signalled that Russia’s control over Eastern Europe was collapsing. Russia had held Eastern Europe in a brutal grip for four and a half decades, since the end of the Second World War.


3. Lies against socialism answered

Marxism and Stalinism

“But socialism is dead, darling!” This was one response on the street to the front page of Socialist Organiser with the headline: ‘Stand up for socialism’ And there were many similar responses, sad as well as gleeful.


7. What was the Bolsheviks’ conception of the 1917 revolution?

Marxism and Stalinism

The erstwhile rulers of the Stalinist system — which they said was the realisation of socialism — are now working openly for the restoration of capitalism. So are most of those they rule, and in the first place the working class.


12. And where were Jacob Sverdlov's sons?

Marxists
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

AND WHERE WERE JACOB SVERDLOV'S SONS?

Sverdlov killed the bloody Tsar,
He signed the warrant for it;
So when they struck his statue down
The Tsarists cheered who saw it:


"The New Course" and "The Struggle for the New Course"

Leon Trotsky

Leon Trotsky's "The New Course" and Max Shachtman's "The Struggle for the New Course".


OCTOBER 1917

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate
Author: 
SM

OCTOBER 1917
Who fears to praise Red Seventeen?
Who quails at Lenin’s name?
When liars jeer at Trotsky's fate
Who adds his, “Theirs the blame”?


PRAGUE, NOVEMBER '89

Eastern Europe
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

PRAGUE, NOVEMBER '89
"It's a pity I'm so old", the woman said,
"But still I'm glad. Oh, I'm glad, I'm glad!"
And sad, like one who knows she'll soon be dead.


Workers' Liberty 3/22: Max Shachtman on Isaac Deutscher's "Trotsky"

Leon Trotsky

Can socialism be built through tyranny? Max Shachtman on Isaac Deutscher's "Trotsky". Download as pdf (see "attachment")


THE CURSE OF TROTSKY

Ireland
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

THE CURSE OF TROTSKY

Two things I cursed are gone out of the world

DeValera's sealed green Catholic arcadia,
Small frail redout of revenant Gaels: epigones


COLLAGE FOR A BLEAK APRIL

Leon Trotsky
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

COLLAGE FOR A BLEAK APRIL

[The fourth part of this is
also listed separately as:
"What Is To Be Done?"]


SYPHILIS

Marxism and Stalinism
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

SYPHILIS
(After reading Isaac Babel's
story "Guy De Maupassant")

De Maupassaunt died at forty four
Crawling on hands and knees,
Eating his own shit,
His syphyllitic brain raddled,


KARL MARX IN AUGUST

Karl Marx
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

KARL MARX IN AUGUST
(To the tune of "Joe Hill")

I dreamed I saw Karl Marx last night,
I saw him standing there,
His hair jet black, no longer white,
Fierce eyes, with a bold young stare:


We fight the sea at Kronstadt

History
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

We fight the sea at Kronstadt

Across the frozen, hostile, misted sea


Cliff's State Capitalism in Perspective 3

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

For the whole article online, click here. For part 3 of it published in three parts, read on.


Cliff's State Capitalism in Perspective — Part 1

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

For the whole article online, click here. For part 1 of it published in three parts, read on.


After the Dictatorship of the Lie

Marxism and Stalinism
Author: 
Sean Matgamna

Russian and East European Stalinism collapsed in 1989-91. It was replaced not, as socialist had hoped, by working class rule, but by the capitalism of the state-looting oligarchs.


Stalinism and the defeat of the workers - North London AWL branch meeting

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate
11 Mar 2008 - 7:30pm
11 Mar 2008 - 9:30pm

Location: 

Red Rose, 127 Seven Sisters Road, near Finsbury Park tube (Picc/Victoria)


Description: 

North London's AWL branch meetings are open to all. At the moment we are doing a series on the life and work of Leon Trotsky. This week the focus is on the defeat of the Russian Revolution by Stalinism.

Trotsky argues that Stalinism was not the logical product of Bolshevism, but represented a bureaucratic counter-revolution against the Russian working class - separated from Bolshevism by "a river of blood"

Suggested reading: The Revolution Betrayed (1936) - http://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1936/revbet/index.htm. Short reading: chapter 11: Whither the Soviet Union?

For more info contact David Broder - 07828 844695/davidthetrot@googlemail.com


Trotsky's New Course - North London AWL branch meeting

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate
26 Feb 2008 - 7:30pm
26 Feb 2008 - 9:30pm

Location: 

Red Rose, 127 Seven Sisters Road, near Finsbury Park tube (Picc/Victoria)


Description: 

North London's AWL branch meetings are open to all. At the moment we are doing a series on the life and work of Leon Trotsky. This week the focus is on The Soviet Union after the Revolution and 'The New Course.'

“The struggle against the bureaucratism of the state apparatus is an exceptionally important but prolonged task, one that runs more or less parallel to our other fundamental tasks: economic reconstruction and the elevation of the cultural level of the masses. The most important historical instrument for the accomplishment of all these tasks is the party. Naturally, not even the party can tear itself away from the social and cultural conditions of the country. But as the voluntary organization of the vanguard, of the best, the most active and the most conscious elements of the working class, it is able to preserve itself much better than can the state apparatus from the tendencies of bureaucratism. For that, it must see the danger clearly and combat it without let up.”

Reading: The New Course (1923) -
http://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1923/newcourse/index.htm.

Short Reading: Chapter 1: the question of party generations.

For more info contact David Broder - 07828 844695/davidthetrot@googlemail.com


The Ukrainian Revolution 1917-1921: Deciding the fate of European socialist revolution

Eastern Europe
Author: 
Chris Ford

On the ninetieth anniversary of the Russian Revolution it is important to recognise that it was more than a Russian event. It swept across the entire Russian Empire with the long oppressed nations making their bid for freedom. The most important challenge was in “Russia’s Ireland” – Ukraine. To mark the anniversary of the proclamation of the Ukrainian Peoples Republic ninety years ago on November 22, 1917 this article examines the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917-21, which was pivotal in deciding the fate not only of the Russian Revolution but the entire European socialist Revolution.


1917 + 90 — Leon Trotsky: All power to the soviets!

Leon Trotsky

This is the 90th anniversary of the Russian workers’ revolution of November 1917. Since the fall in 1991 of the Stalinist regime which eventually overwhelmed the workers’ government and made a counter-revolution in the 1920s, more has been available to researchers in the west. Some new books have advanced our understanding of the revolution. None, however, can match the exciting exposition of the course of 1917, in Trotsky’s History of the Russian Revolution


Alexandra Kollontai: Socialist Feminist

Women
Author: 
ROSALIND ROBSON

The Russian revolutionary, Alexandra Kollontai, is best known for her organisational work among Russian working class women prior to, and immediately after, the 1917 revolution and her writings on sexual morality and the family. She has become better known largely as the result of feminist interest in her life and career.


1917: how the workers made a revolution

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate

Download whole pamphlet as pdf (12MB). The pamphlet was published in November 1987, on the 70th anniversary of the 1917 revolution.


Reading for dayschool on Russian revolution, 1 September 2007

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate

1. For a timeline of the revolution, click here.

2. For a short summary article from We stand for workers' liberty, click here.

3. For a PDF of the AWL pamphlet 1917: how the workers made a revolution (published in 1987 on the 70th anniversary of the revolution), click here. (Warning: this is quite a large file, 12MB.) 32 pages long, this is an excellent overview, also including articles on less well-known issues connected to the revolution such as the national question, women's liberation and black liberation.


Revolution and counter-revolution in Russia: a timeline

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate

1917

February (March by the western calendar): workers' demonstrations in Russia overthrow the Tsar (king). Prince Lvov leads Provisional Government; Petrograd workers set up a "Soviet" (workers' councils).


AWL day school on the Russian Revolution

The Russian Revolution and Its Fate
1 Sep 2007 - 12:00pm
1 Sep 2007 - 5:30pm
description:

A dayschool for new activists

12-5.30pm, Saturday 1 September, The (Kings Cross rail or tube)

This year is the 90th anniversary of the Russian revolution. But why take the Russian revolution as a model? Isn't it irrelevant nowadays, or worse, proof that revolution can't work? Didn't the Bolsheviks lead to Stalin's dictatorship?

Location:
Lucas Arms, 245A Grays Inn Road, Kings Cross

Syndicate content