Battle of Ideas

Articles on Greece and Syriza


An emergency programme to fight racism in Greece Theodora Polenta, 28th January 2015

Speak Greek to the bosses! Editorial, 28th January 2015

Greece shakes Europe Micheál McEoin, 28th January 2015

The ANEL coalition Theodora Polenta, 28th January 2015

Let Greece breathe! Colin Foster, 21st January, 2015

A collection of articles on Greece going back to July 2014, with a link to older articles.

Around the world: 

Borotba: charlatanism masquerading as socialism

Author: 

Dale Street

Introduction

“Hah, hah! Everybody is laughing at Borotba now!” read a comment posted beneath one of the articles translated below, after last November’s sham elections in the Lugansk and Donetsk ‘People’s Republics’ had reinforced right-wing control of the two ‘People’s Republics’.

In Britain, however, Borotba is still treated as a credible organisation and a reliable source of information – above all by the “Solidarity with the Anti-Fascist Resistance” (SARU) campaign and by the various organisations affiliated to it.

Borotba's Stalinist politics: articles from the Ukrainian left.

Around the world: 

Discussing the issues behind the rise of the left in Greece

A group of young socialist activists from Britain are going on a delegation to Greece between 23 and 26 January, to be there during the election. Six of the delegation members took part in the dayschool which London Workers' Liberty held on 18 January, alongside a good size group of other young people, to discuss the political issues behind Greece's dramatic political situation.

A report of the dayschool on Greece held by Workers' Liberty on 18 January.

Around the world: 

Resolution on Greece (January 2015)

We want the left-wing party Syriza to win the Greek elections on 25 January. What else should socialists say?

The following resolution on Greece was written and passed at the Workers' Liberty national committee on 17 January. (See the resolution we published in January 2013, when the period of intense, even pre-revolutionary, struggles in Greece had not yet clearly come to an end.)

A resolution on the situation in Greece passed at the Workers' Liberty national committee on 17 January, eight days before the Greek election.

Around the world: 

The issues after Charlie Hebdo

Author: 

Yves Coleman

This article will not deal in detail with the facts about the two murderous attacks, on 7 January at the headquarters of the weekly Charlie Hebdo and on 9 January in a Parisian kosher supermarket, which have been widely explained in the media; but with some of the problems and discussions inside the radical left and anarchist circles

Most of the left and the anarchist groups, in France, as in other countries, have adopted one of two opposite and wrong attitudes.

A French socialist writes: The left has not been able to clearly denounce the Islamist murders in Paris without either overstressing the importance of Islamophobia, or overstressing the reactionary character of Islam...

Issues and Campaigns: 

Around the world: 

Publications: 

Finance and the "other exploitation"

Review of Costas Lapavitsas: Profiting without producing, Verso 2013


Capitalist exploitation is not just by the boss extracting from the worker, in return for a meagre more-or-less “living wage”, an expansible value-added which may be something like three times what’s paid out in wages.

It also comes from making working-class households pay interest on debts which they run up, often on disadvantageous terms, because of their relative poverty and relative lack of power in the markets.

Marxist Theory and History: 

Back to basics in the unions!

Author: 

Ira Berkovic

The most explosive and inspiring flashes of class struggle in Britain in the three years since the defeat of the public sector pensions dispute have not been national-level pitched battles between large employers and/or the government, and one or several big unions, but local-scale struggles, usually over pay.

Outsourced cleaners at the University of London and SOAS have won significant victories, bringing the workers nearer to parity with their directly employed colleagues’ sick pay, holiday entitlement, and pension arrangements.

How can revolutionary socialists in the labour movement help workplace struggles, spread them, catalyse new ones, give them a political perspective?

Publications: 

Trade Unions: 

A reply to Simon Hardy on Islamism and imperialism

Simon Hardy’s article criticising “The AWL on Islamism” avoids the wilder claims made against us, but it looks as if he has not read Sean Matgamna’s 2006 piece very thoroughly, or thought about it very hard.

Does Workers' Liberty ignore the role of imperialism in the rise of Islamism? Or does much of the British left reproduce a simplistic picture which blurs over Islamism's counter-revolutionary character?

Issues and Campaigns: 

What should socialists do in the General Election?

Author: 

Editorial

In the run up to the general election in May, Workers’ Liberty will be supporting the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, which combines advocating a Labour government with using the election to boost working-class struggles and raise the profile of socialist ideas. We call on other socialists and labour movement militants, whatever your affiliation, to join the campaign.

The Tories remaining in office would be a disaster for the working class. Yet the only alternative government is Ed Miliband’s Labour Party, committed to a softer version of cuts and anti-migrant politics. What should socialists do?

Publications: 

The AWL, Labour and the Left: 

University bans conference under pressure from far right

Author: 

Gerry Bates

The cancellation by Birkbeck University management of room bookings for a 13 December conference on "Institutional Islamophobia" should be condemned.

Following the bans on the Socialist Workers Party by Goldsmiths Students' Union and Edinburgh University Students' Association, and the attempt to ban the SWP in University of Sussex SU, this is yet another blow to freedom of speech and organisation on campuses.

Birkbeck University cancels room booking for an Islamist-organised conference under pressure from anti-Muslim far right.

Publications: 

Issues and Campaigns: 

A “New Labor” in America?

Author: 

Ira Berkovic

Before the tragic discovery that she has a brain tumour, Chicago Teachers Union president Karen Lewis, the public figurehead of the CTU’s 2012 strike against the city’s Democratic mayor Rahm Emanuel, was preparing a mayoral campaign for next year’s election.

For anyone interested in building working-class power in America, the question of how to break through anti-union hostility amongst industrial workers in the South is a real one.

Around the world: 

Trade Unions: 

Publications: 

The socialist answer to UKIP

Author: 

Editorial

Tory defector Douglas Carswell became UKIP’s first elected MP on 9 October, and another Tory defector, Mark Reckless, may win on 20 November in Rochester and Strood. We examine UKIP’s manifesto.

UKIP: “Migrants are a drain on UK resources, including benefits and NHS”

A socialist response to UKIP's mainfesto.

Publications: 

Issues and Campaigns: 

Marxism and imperialism

Author: 

Martin Thomas

By the end of the 60s, what had once been “the pride” of Marxism — the theory of imperialism — had become a “tower of Babel”, in which not even Marxists knew any longer how to find their way. Giovanni Arrighi

Maybe the first big classical-Marxist statement on imperialism was by Karl Kautsky, in 1899, replying to Eduard Bernstein’s call for a “revision” of the perspective of Marx and Engels.

Publications: 

Marxist Theory and History: 

'Trotskyism' in Wonderland: 'Workers Power' and Ukraine

Author: 

Dale Street

Events in Ukraine in 2014 divided the left in Britain, just as they divided the left internationally.

In Britain one the organisations most vociferous in arguing that the Maidan protests were dominated by fascists, culminated in a fascist-led coup, and then triggered a genocidal civil war against the forces of the anti-fascist resistance was Workers Power (WP).

A review of the literature on Ukraine produced by Workers Power, the British left group which has apologised most prolifically for Russian nationalism and imperialism.

Around the world: 

The AWL, Labour and the Left: 

Publications: 

“If we burn, you burn with us”

Author: 

Daisy Thomas

“If we burn, you burn with us” — those were the fighting words that rallied support behind the symbol of the rebellion: The Mockingjay.

Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence), when pushed to her limit, became the symbol of hope and change that Panem’s Districts were so dearly in need of. ‘The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1’ was 123 minutes of being on the edge of your seat, almost holding your breath to see what would unfold next. Even though I had read the books, I found that the cinematography, acting, and screenwriting were compelling enough for me lose myself in the narrative.

A review of The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1.

Publications: 

Culture and Reviews: 

Israel: “an anti-democratic bill”

Author: 

Alternative Information Centre in Jerusalem

A bill defining Israel as “the nation state of the Jewish people” was passed on Sunday 23 November by the Israeli cabinet, despite protests that this bill undermines the “democratic” character of Israel and discriminates against Israel’s Palestinian citizens, who comprise 20% of the population.

Fourteen ministers supported the bill while Justice Minister Livni and five ministers from the Yesh Atid party voted against.

A bill defining Israel as “the nation state of the Jewish people” was passed on Sunday 23 November by the Israeli cabinet, despite protests that this bill undermines the “democratic” character of Israel and discriminates against Israel’s Palestinian citizens, who comprise 20% of the population.

Publications: 

Around the world: 

From the Youth of All Nations

Author: 

H C Harwood

From the Youth of All Nations reads to me as a bitter complaint against the ruling classes on all sides of the First World War playing out their arguments with the sufferings and lives of soldiers.

Its title declares both a bitterness of the young against old leaders, and an internationalist outlook. Then its fifteen four-line (quatrain) stanzas spell out the manipulations of the call to war and promise rebellion rather than reverence. The strict iambic tetrameter rhythm creates an impression of an army marching to settle scores with its rulers.

From the Youth of All Nations by H C Harwood is a bitter complaint against the ruling classes on all sides of the First World War playing out their arguments with the sufferings and lives of soldiers.

Publications: 

Culture and Reviews: 

Employers discuss plans to undermine unions

In leaked documents from HMRC (the tax and customs part of the civil service) we see in the open how bosses try to “handle” unions.

In the document a senior manager writes:“...If we are unable to persuade the new GEC (the union body that runs the PCS union in HMRC) and full time officials to change their stance this suggests that the usual rules for engagement with a trade union will not work.”

The paper recommends “aiming to marginalise PCS by maintaining dialogue only to meet statutory minimum requirements.”

Leaked documents show how civil service bosses try to “handle” unions.

Trade Unions: 

Publications: 

Is technology to blame?

Author: 

Bruce Robinson

In her claims that exposure to Facebook is the cause of changes to the brain and thus at the root of a range of behavioural and social problems, Susan Greenfield adopts positions that regularly reappear as science and technology develop (discussed in Solidarity 342 and 343).

There is a tendency to blame new technologies for whatever worries happen to be top of the agenda of social conservatives.

Publications: 

Issues and Campaigns: 

Stop landlord rip-offs:control rents!

Author: 

Colin Foster

The tenants’ campaign on the New Era estate in Hoxton, east London, has spotlighted the rise of a fight back by private tenants.

“When our estate was bought by new owners”, say the New Era tenants, “we were given rent rises of 10% and told to expect greater rises next year, as the new owners wanted rents to be at ‘market levels’. In Hoxton... this means over £500 a week”.

Current rents are about £160 a week, so most tenants face being forced out of their homes.

Three trends have come together.

The tenants’ campaign on the New Era estate in Hoxton, east London, has spotlighted the rise of a fight back by private tenants.

Publications: 

Issues and Campaigns: 

Pages